Skip to main content
Tech Radar TechRadar the technology experts
Sign in
  • View Profile
  • Sign out
RSS
Asia
flag of Singapore
Singapore
Europe
flag of Danmark
Danmark
flag of Suomi
Suomi
flag of Norge
Norge
flag of Sverige
Sverige
flag of UK
UK
flag of Italia
Italia
flag of Nederland
Nederland
flag of België (Nederlands)
België (Nederlands)
flag of France
France
flag of Deutschland
Deutschland
flag of España
España
North America
flag of US (English)
US (English)
flag of Canada
Canada
flag of México
México
Australasia
flag of Australia
Australia
flag of New Zealand
New Zealand
  • Phones
  • Computing
  • TVs
  • AI
  • Streaming
  • Health
  • Audio
  • VPN
  • More
    • Cameras
    • Home
    • News
    • Reviews
    • Opinion
    • How to
    • Versus
    • Deals
    • Coupons
    • Best
Tech Radar Pro
Tech Radar Gaming
Trending
  • Amazon Prime Day
  • Back to school
  • Nintendo Switch 2
  • Best VPN
  • ChatGPT
  • NYT Wordle today
  • Best laptop
  • Best web hosting
Recommended reading
Best PC controllers
Gaming Best PC controllers in 2025: top gamepads from GameSir, Thrustmaster and more
Nacon vs Turtle Beach controller
Gaming Nacon Revolution X Unlimited vs Turtle Beach Stealth Pivot – here’s what I learned testing two of the year’s most interesting Xbox controllers
Best Xbox controllers 2025
Gaming Accessories The best Xbox controllers in 2025
Best PS5 controllers DualSense Edge
PS5 Best PS5 controllers in 2025
Prime Day controller deals
Gaming Prime Day is ending soon, but you still have a chance to buy these amazing controllers for less than $50
an image of the Thrustmaster SimTask FarmStick PlayStation and a DualSense controller
Gaming Accessories Say hello to one of the most niche PS5 controllers you’ll see this year
Hideo Kojima holding the upcoming Death Stranding 2 DualSense.
Gaming PlayStation fans blast 'lazy' new Death Stranding 2: On the Beach DualSense Wireless Controller
  1. Gaming

5 of the weirdest videogame controllers that almost happened

News
By Jon Porter published 2 July 2016

From stars to boomerangs

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

Introduction

Introduction

This week saw Microsoft reveal some of its early Xbox controller designs from before the console's launch in 1999, and they're pretty outlandish.

Usually these early prototypes remain shrouded in secrecy, but these images offer a rare glimpse into the development process of the controllers that we end up holding for hundreds of hours.

In honor of the reveal of the Xbox's aborted controller attempts we decided to revisit four other weird and wonderful controller ideas that for better or for worse never made it to market.

Page 1 of 6
Page 1 of 6
X-Wing-Box

X-Wing-Box

The first thing that strikes you about the look of the Xbox controller prototypes is the small LCD screen at the centre of each of them.

It's not surprising given that the soon-to-be-released Dreamcast also featured a similar screen as part of its controller. It was rarely used for anything interesting, but the thinking was that the screen could be used to display small pieces of information that could be taken off the television screen.

The feature would later be taken to its logical extreme by the Wii U's gamepad, which functions as a fully-fledged touchscreen in its own right.

Outside of the LCD screen it's also great to see that Microsoft experimented with some fantastically bizarre shapes for their debut controller. Personally I'm a fan of the UFO-esque design on the bottom left.

Page 2 of 6
Page 2 of 6
PlayStation Analog Joystick

PlayStation Analog Joystick

The dual-joystick gamepad is one of those inventions that's so perfect it's hard to remember a time when it didn't exist. It's like touchscreens before Apple's multi-touch, or bread before sliced bread.

But it took a long time for the industry to reach the dual-joystick standard that exists today. Remember that in arcades the standard was always a single joystick alongside several buttons, and the Nintendo 64 continued this tradition with its single analogue stick.

Sony may have eventually nailed the dual-joystick design with the original DualShock controller, but that wasn't before its admirable attempt with the Analogue Joystick whose two joysticks more closely resembled massive flight sticks than the much smaller thumb sticks that would eventually become the standard.

Unlike the other entries on this list, the Analog Joystick actually made it to market, but we're including it because of how obvious a stepping stone it is between the original PlayStation controller and the eventual DualShock.

Page 3 of 6
Page 3 of 6
Nintendo Star Controller

Nintendo Star Controller

As it turns out, Nintendo was throwing around some pretty wacky controller prototypes before it eventually settled on the Wii's only-slightly-wacky Wiimote.

The most crazy of these was the Star Controller, a large disk with just four buttons, one of which was a massive Mario star.

The idea appears to have been to have relied almost entirely on motion controls, but as well as being too garish Nintendo's developers also took issue with its ability to control the likes of Mario and Zelda.

Page 4 of 6
Page 4 of 6
The Original Steam Controller

The Original Steam Controller

Valve's Steam Controller came about out of a desire to bring the experience of using a mouse and keyboard to the form factor of a traditional game controller, and with a mission statement like that it was never going to play by the rules.

With no joysticks or face buttons to speak of, Valve's original Steam Controller prototype was unorthodox to say the very least.

The two touch-pads that were intended to replace the former did eventually make it into the finished product, but the central touchscreen was replaced by a more traditional trio of menu buttons flanked by traditional face buttons and a single analogue stick.

Page 5 of 6
Page 5 of 6
The Boomerang

The Boomerang

Nowadays, with the PS4 outselling the Xbox One so decisively, it's weird to think back to a time when Sony were anything other than the king of the mountain, but at the outset of the PS3's life things weren't looking great for the Japanese electronics giant.

The new console might have been expensive and difficult to develop for, but our fondest memory of Sony's darkest days is the PS3's original controller, which looked like a cross between a boomerang and a sci-fi banana.

Thankfully at the following E3 Sony revealed the 'real' PS3 controller, although we would have to wait a further two years until the PS3 got its de facto controller in the form of the Dualshock 3, which finally brought back the much-needed rumble functionality that was absent from the Sixaxis.

Page 6 of 6
Page 6 of 6
TOPICS
Microsoft Sony
Jon Porter
Jon Porter
Social Links Navigation

Jon Porter is the ex-Home Technology Writer for TechRadar. He has also previously written for Practical Photoshop, Trusted Reviews, Inside Higher Ed, Al Bawaba, Gizmodo UK, Genetic Literacy Project, Via Satellite, Real Homes and Plant Services Magazine, and you can now find him writing for The Verge.

Read more
Best PC controllers
Best PC controllers in 2025: top gamepads from GameSir, Thrustmaster and more
Nacon vs Turtle Beach controller
Nacon Revolution X Unlimited vs Turtle Beach Stealth Pivot – here’s what I learned testing two of the year’s most interesting Xbox controllers
Best Xbox controllers 2025
The best Xbox controllers in 2025
Best PS5 controllers DualSense Edge
Best PS5 controllers in 2025
Prime Day controller deals
Prime Day is ending soon, but you still have a chance to buy these amazing controllers for less than $50
an image of the Thrustmaster SimTask FarmStick PlayStation and a DualSense controller
Say hello to one of the most niche PS5 controllers you’ll see this year
Latest in Gaming
Meta Quest 3S on cyan background with TechRadar price cut sign
Prime Day is almost over, so I'm begging you to scoop up the best VR headset around at its lowest price before it's too late
Dragon Quest 3 HD-2D Remake
One of the all-time best RPGs just shot down to its lowest ever Switch price as Amazon Prime Day comes to a close
Final Fantasy 1 Amazon Prime Day deals.
Get six incredible Nintendo Switch RPGs at a record low price – it's literally under eight dollars per game
Three DualSense controller on a green background with white big savings text
Turns out the best PS5 DualSense deals this Prime Day aren't even at Amazon - they're at this retailer instead
Prime Day KontrolFreek deals.
I rely on these thumbstick add-ons for my sweatiest gaming sessions – and they could be yours for less than $15 or £10
The Thrustmaster eSwap X pro controller on a green background with white big savings text
I think this is one of the best Xbox controllers ever made – and it's had its price slashed for Prime Day
Latest in News
The Oakley Meta HSTN smart glasses being used by a basketball player
You can finally preorder the Oakley Meta smart glasses, but there's a catch
Squid Game's masked enforcers line up in a V formation
Squid Game: The Challenge season 3 is a win for Netflix, but one unhinged game from the K-drama can’t be replicated
Intel Core Ultra processor
Intel CEO reportedly admits 'it is too late for us' to catch AI leaders like Nvidia, but here's how it could still recover
Dr. Collins wears surgical robes and glasses, looking on
Tracy Ifeachor exits The Pitt as Dr. Collins in shock casting shakeup, and that’s bad news for season 2 of the hit HBO Max show
Mel folds her arms while looking at Jack, who has his hands on his hips
Virgin River season 8 gets early renewal from Netflix, and this season 6 cliffhanger could be a sneaky red herring
Man with laptop showing Blue screen of death or BSOD on the monitor screen
Microsoft says Black Screen of Death better 'aligns with Windows 11's visual style' - but I think the new crash screen is missing a key detail
LATEST ARTICLES
  1. 1
    Last chance: get AirPods Pro 2 at the lowest price ever before Prime Day ends
  2. 2
    Don't miss your chance to upgrade your gaming PC setup this Prime Day – save up to 60% off Razer gear
  3. 3
    Prime Day’s nearly over, but you can still save on an Echo Show and get Alexa+ early
  4. 4
    Prime Day is nearly over, but you can still snag a deal on these 3 TVs I’ve tested and recommend – and they’re all under $1,000
  5. 5
    Prime Day is almost over, but the Sonos Ace are still at the lowest price ever

TechRadar is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site.

  • About Us
  • Contact Future's experts
  • Contact Us
  • Terms and conditions
  • Privacy policy
  • Cookies policy
  • Advertise with us
  • Web notifications
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Careers

© Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.

Please login or signup to comment

Please wait...