New Prime Video movie My Old Ass is a hilarious comedy with a time-travel twist that I can't wait to watch – and it has 90% on Rotten Tomatoes

Aubrey Plaza sits on a log next to Maddie Ziegler in My Old Ass
My Old Ass is on Prime Video's top 10 movies list (Image credit: Amazon MGM Studios)

Currently sitting on Prime Video's top 10 movies list is the sci-fi comedy My Old Ass, which has become a huge hit since it was added to the streamer on November 8 following its limited theatrical run.

My Old Ass is yet another top 10 title I can't wait to watch alongside Prime Video's #1 movie, Spanish zombie thriller Apocalypse Z: The Beginning of the End. With nearly 200 movies being added to Prime Video this month, My Old Ass has managed to see off tough competition to become one of the most-watched movies on one of the best streaming services .

As a fan of the undead, I quickly devoured the new Prime Video movie Apocalypse Z: The Beginning of the End after it was released. However, I'm planning to give myself a break from all the zombie horror and watch this coming-of-age dramedy with a sci-fi twist. With my favorite comedic actress, Aubrey Plaza, involved, my expectations are high.

What is My Old Ass about?

My Old Ass | Official Trailer - YouTube My Old Ass | Official Trailer - YouTube
Watch On

Plaza was a hit with viewers in her role in Marvel's WandaVision spin-off series Agatha All Along on Disney Plus, and she's set to win more fans in My Old Ass, a movie with an outrageous plot.

In My Old Ass, an 18th birthday mushroom trip introduces Elliott (Maisy Stella) to her witty 39-year-old self (Plaza). When Elliott's "old ass" starts issuing warnings to her younger self, young Elliot realizes that she has to rethink everything about family and love, over a life-changing summer before she heads off to college in Toronto.

My Old Ass has swiftly become one of the best Prime Video movies with its 90% score on Rotten Tomatoes, and it's also garnering rave reviews. The Guardian wrote that My Old Ass "looks as glossy and poppy as a studio comedy from the 2000s, a rich treat at a time when that has become the rare exception rather than the rule. It deserves to find an equally big audience, for asses both young and old."

Meanwhile, Christy Lemire said on RobertEbert.com: "Plaza looks nothing like Stella, which is part of the joke, but the two actresses match each other with their sardonic wit. Plaza's deadpan meets Stella's effervescence, and somewhere in that giddy mix, you quickly believe these two are one."

After falling in love with Plaza's performance in The White Lotus season 2, it was a pleasure to watch her show off her dramatic side once again in Emily the Criminal. Now, I can't wait to see her bring her signature deadpan humor to what looks like a refreshing new comedy.

You might also like

Grace Morris
Entertainment Writer

After graduating with a degree in Writing and Film Studies, Grace dived into the world of entertainment where she started writing all about the must-watch shows and movies at What To Watch. Now Grace is on her next writing adventure at TechRadar, where she uses her expertise to help readers keep up to date on the biggest TV shows and movies in the ever-changing world of streaming. If she’s not writing about her passion for entertainment, you’ll find her watching reality shows while feasting on chocolate. 

Read more
A still from the movie Captain Phillips
4 new Prime Video movies with over 90% on Rotten Tomatoes that I recommend watching
Fargo
3 new movies on Prime Video with over 95% on Rotten Tomatoes
Lainy straps on a fake baby bump in front of a mirror in Kinda Pregnant.
Netflix's #1 movie Kinda Pregnant is kinda bad – here are 3 better comedies with over 95% on Rotten Tomatoes to watch instead
A promotional image for The Fall Guy, which shows Ryan Gosling and Emily Blunt in front of an explosion
3 new Prime Video movies I'm excited to watch in January 2025
Jillian Bell and Amy Schumer in a still from Netflix's new movie Kinda Pregnant
5 new Netflix and Prime Video movies with less than 48% on Rotten Tomatoes I suggest you avoid
The trio Kneecap from their movie of the same name
I streamed more movies and shows than ever before in January 2025 – here are 9 of my favorites on Netflix, Prime Video, and more
Latest in Amazon Prime Video
A TV in a living room with the language settings displayed
Prime Video is testing AI dubbing to make movies and shows more accessible – and might avoid the backlash that hit Netflix
watch back to the future online
Everything new on Prime Video in March 2025
Michael Iskander as David in House of David.
House of David is Prime Video's #2 most-watched show – here are 3 more historical dramas to watch next
An angry Mark Grayson flying towards the camera in Invincible season 3 episode 7
Invincible season 3 episode 7 ending explained: who dies, who plays Conquest, who is Ka-Hor, and more big questions answered
A close up of Conquest in Invincible season 3 episode 7
Invincible season 3 episode 7 just made good on a two-year-old Instagram post and a wild rumor about Jeffrey Dean Morgan
A collage image of Eddie Marsan and Jamie Campbell Bower posing at different read carpet events
The Rings of Power season 3 adds Stranger Things' Jamie Campbell Bower and Heartstopper's Eddie Marsan to its cast, and I think they're perfect for two specific roles
Latest in News
Stock photographs of people smiling and looking at laptops in a small business environment.
This web hosting platform elevates your online presence
The Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge on display at Galaxy Unpacked
Exclusive: the Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge will have durability to match its ‘sexy’ form
Metaphor: ReFantazio
Sega was Metacritic's highest-rated publisher of 2024 thanks to the critically acclaimed Metaphor: ReFantazio and Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth
AirPods Pro Review
Apple has quietly updated its guidance on how to clean your AirPods, and suggests you buy a kit… from Belkin
China
Chinese hackers who targeted key US infrastructure charged by Justice Department
A screen shot of Lady Gaga in her interview with Zane Lowe for Apple Music
Lady Gaga’s Spotify press conference is being live streamed today – here’s where you can watch Spotify’s big step forward in fan inclusion