Prime Video's On Call has been robbed of good reviews – here are 3 better crime dramas with over 85% on Rotten Tomatoes

Donald Glover and Francesca Sloane in Prime Video's Mr and Mrs Smith
(Image credit: Prime Video / Amazon)

Prime Video is no stranger to a compelling crime drama series, with a large majority of them making up the best Prime Video shows. However, it's new procedural drama On Call hasn't appeared to hit home with critics, landing a below-average score of 54% on Rotten Tomatoes at the time of writing (it has to be said that audiences have given it a much more favorable 90%).

Set in Long Beach, California, the show follows veteran training officer Traci Harmon (Troian Bellisario) and her novice partner Alex Diaz (Brandon Larracuente), who have the responsibility of keeping the local community safe while they process the recent loss of their colleague. For a brand-new show on one of the best streaming services, the early reviews aren't great, but since Prime Video's library is one of the most vast out there, we have three other crime dramas to recommend that are more worthy of your time and attention.

Whether it's espionage, a detective story, or a tense court drama, these three shows are some of Prime Video's finest and unlike On Call, each have respectable Rotten Tomatoes score of over 85% with the critics.

The Fall

  • RT score: 85%
  • Age rating: TV-PG
  • Runtime: ~60 minutes
  • Creator: Allan Cubitt

Set in the environment of the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI), detective Stella Gibson (Gillian Anderson) is drafted from the London Metropolitan Police to assist the PSNI when a serial killer goes on a spree attacking young women around Belfast. As the case unravels, Gibson learns that run-of-the-mill father and husband Paul Spector (Jamie Dornan) is leading a double life as family man and serial killer hiding in plain sight.

With no prior experience to cases this severe, the PSNI puts its trust into the hands of Gibson, who is their only hope to putting a stop to the violent murders and take down the perpetrator. While the show is available on Prime Video in the US and Australia, it's streaming on Netflix in the UK.

Mr and Mrs Smith

Mr. & Mrs. Smith Season 1 - Official Trailer | Prime Video - YouTube Mr. & Mrs. Smith Season 1 - Official Trailer | Prime Video - YouTube
Watch On
  • RT score: 91%
  • Age rating: TV-MA
  • Runtime: ~42 minutes
  • Creator: Francesca Sloane & Donald Glover

A recent addition to Prime Video's extensive library of TV shows, Mr and Mrs Smith takes inspiration from the 2005 movie of the same name starring power couple at the time Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt. But Sloane and Glover's reimagining of the '00s classic adopts a more modern approach.

When two strangers independently agree to take on a job as agents, they find themselves assuming different identities as a married couple. With their missions and instructions being sent to them from a mysterious text source, each episode sees the pair tackle a different mission using their spy skills while forming a marriage-like relationship.

Goliath

GOLIATH Season 1 TRAILER (2016) New Amazon Series - YouTube GOLIATH Season 1 TRAILER (2016) New Amazon Series - YouTube
Watch On
  • RT score: 86%
  • Age rating: TV-MA
  • Runtime: ~50 minutes
  • Creator: David E. Kelley & Jonathan Shapiro

Goliath was a powerhouse of a show, airing from 2016 until its fourth and final season in 2021. In this legal drama, former lawyer Billy McBride (Billy Bob Thornton) is now a disgraced ambulance chaser who's presented with a wrongful death case against a law firm giant with whom he was once affiliated. When he agrees to take on the case, his team finds themselves at the centre of a life-or-death trial that could make or break his chance at redemption.

You might also like

Rowan Davies
Editorial Associate

Rowan is an Editorial Associate and Apprentice Writer for TechRadar. A recent addition to the news team, he is involved in generating stories for topics that spread across TechRadar's categories. His interests in audio tech and knowledge in entertainment culture help bring the latest updates in tech news to our readers. 

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.

Read more
Cross sitting in a car with his arm on the window and looking at something off camera.
Prime Video's #1 show Cross has captivated subscribers – here are 3 other crime thrillers with over 90% on Rotten Tomatoes to investigate next
Alfred Molina in promo for Prime Video's miniseries Three Pines
Enjoyed The Rig season two? Here are 3 more Prime Video thriller shows to watch next
Fleabag (Phoebe Waller-Bridge) with tears streaming down her cheeks as she looks into the camera.
Prime Video’s most-watched shows are a mixed bag – here are 3 with flawless 100% Rotten Tomatoes scores
Keanu Reeves as an animated character in Secret Level.
Secret Level is Prime Video’s new hit show, but it’s game over with the critics – here are 3 better anthology series to watch
Traci puts her hands on Alex's shoulders to comfort him in On Call.
Prime Video's new trailer for police drama On Call has an exciting twist, and looks like an adrenaline junkie's dream
Angie, Quinn, Tye and Camille laughing at each other against a yellow background in Harlem.
3 new Prime Video shows I can't wait to watch this month, including one with 98% on Rotten Tomatoes
Latest in Amazon Prime Video
A collage image of Eddie Marsan and Jamie Campbell Bower posing at different read carpet events
The Rings of Power season 3 adds Stranger Things' Jamie Campbell Bower and Heartstopper's Eddie Marsan to its cast, and I think they're perfect for two specific roles
Jared Padalecki, Misha Collins, and Jensen Ackles at an event for The CW's Supernatural TV show
Prime Video puts a Supernatural spin on The Boys season 5 cast as Jared Padalecki and Misha Collins sign on to the popular show in mystery roles
Nicole Kidman as Nancy Vandergroot in Holland
Nicole Kidman's new Prime Video thriller, Holland, looks quirky and unsettling in its first trailer
Mark Grayson with blood on his face and costume in Invincible season 3
Invincible season 3 episode 6's mid-credits scene just confirmed the Prime Video show's next two episodes will be an absolute bloodbath
Jack Reacher looking down a street in Reacher season 3 on Prime Video
Reacher season 3 is Prime Video's #1 show – here are 3 more action shows that pack a punch with over 80% on Rotten Tomatoes
Guillaume Cyr, Margo Martindale, and Chris Diamantopoulos hide, bloodied, behind a couch in The Sticky
Prime Video reveals a not so sweet surprise as it cancels hit crime comedy series The Sticky after one season
Latest in Features
Honor Earbuds open, in early testing
The top 3 ground-breaking earbuds innovations we saw at MWC 2025
Sony Bravia 9 backlight demo showing images on screen and on raw backlight
TCL overtaking LG's premium TV sales is the inevitable result of OLED's biggest problem and mini-LED's biggest strength
The XPANCEO Biosensing smart contact lens at MWC, displaying on a forked monolith
The three best health and fitness products unveiled at MWC 2025
An animated girl holds up a paddle with a whale behind her
3 new movies and shows on Disney+ and Hulu that I can't wait to stream
Divine G looking at his fellow theater group performers in Sing Sing
6 Max movies and shows I’m most excited to watch in March, from A24 horrors to an offbeat Adult Swim animation
AWS for telecom logo at MWC 2025
Here’s 5 cool things I got to see AWS is doing with AI and 5G at MWC 2025