Skip to main content
Tech Radar TechRadar the technology experts
Sign in
  • View Profile
  • Sign out
RSS
Asia
flag of Singapore
Singapore
Europe
flag of Danmark
Danmark
flag of Suomi
Suomi
flag of Norge
Norge
flag of Sverige
Sverige
flag of UK
UK
flag of Italia
Italia
flag of Nederland
Nederland
flag of België (Nederlands)
België (Nederlands)
flag of France
France
flag of Deutschland
Deutschland
flag of España
España
North America
flag of US (English)
US (English)
flag of Canada
Canada
flag of México
México
Australasia
flag of Australia
Australia
flag of New Zealand
New Zealand
  • Phones
  • Computing
  • TVs
  • AI
  • Streaming
  • Health
  • Audio
  • VPN
  • More
    • Cameras
    • Home
    • News
    • Reviews
    • Opinion
    • How to
    • Versus
    • Deals
    • Coupons
    • Best
Tech Radar Pro
Tech Radar Gaming
Trending
  • Amazon Prime Day
  • Back to school
  • Nintendo Switch 2
  • Best VPN
  • ChatGPT
  • NYT Wordle today
  • Best laptop
  • Best web hosting
Recommended reading
A still of a woman pointing a gun from Grand Theft Auto 6, next to three Nothing CMF Phone 2 Pro phones, next to some Ray-Ban Meta smart glasses
Tech ICYMI: the 8 biggest tech stories of the week, from ChatGPT's shopping upgrade to GTA 6 delays
Apple
Websites & Apps This rotten Apple ruling cracks the reality distortion field – and I don't know if that's what consumers want
AI
Artificial Intelligence Meta ‘stole’ my book to train its AI – but there’s a bigger problem
Microsoft
Pro Microsoft hit by new legal claim over restrictive licensing and overcharging allegations
A Symfonisk lamp speaker next to a GTA VI character on a motorbike, and the new Windows Surface tablet.
Tech ICYMI: the week's 7 biggest tech stories, from GTA 6's beautiful new trailer to Sony's WH-1000XM6 headphones teaser
The Xbox Series X Digital next to the new Dyson Airwrap and Nothing Headphone (1)
Tech ICYMI: the week's 7 biggest tech stories from Spotify's suspected AI band to Nothing's first over-ear headphones
App Store Payment
iOS Is the App Store about to undergo a big change? Not so fast, says Apple
  1. Gaming
  2. Consoles & PC

Five everyday words that companies claim they own

News
By Jon Porter published 20 June 2016

(TM)I When tech trademarks go wrong

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

Introduction

Introduction

Hello Games has revealed that it has finally won a battle with Sky broadcasting over the right to include the word 'Sky' in the title of its game No Man's Sky.

The news came as a surprise to many, partly because the battle had been going on secretly for three years, but also because the word Sky is a pretty fundamental part of the English language.

Of course battles like this are nothing new. Sky has been consistent in trying to claim exclusive rights to the three letter word which has been a part of the English language since around the 1300s, and Apple's disputes with the Beatles-owned Apple Corps have been extensive enough to generate their own Wikipedia page.

In light of the news, we decided to revisit some of the most weird and wonderful trademark battles of recent years.

Page 1 of 6
Page 1 of 6
It's like comparing Apples with Apples

It's like comparing Apples with Apples

As one of the biggest technology companies in the world it was only natural that one or two firms would attempt to cash in on the luxury branding of Apple's products.

But what's more surprising is that some of these firms have succeeded. Just last month Apple lost a court battle in China which means that handbag manufacturer Xintong can continue to use the IPHONE branding on its leather goods.

Back in 2012 Apple was ordered to pay US$60m to Chinese firm Proview to allow it to use the iPad name in China.

Apple claimed that it already had the right to the name iPad as a result of having previously bought the right to use it from Proview's Taiwanese affiliate for a fraction of the cost of the eventual settlement.

But the firm's biggest fight over the Apple name has been with Apple Corps, the company founded by the Beatles to manage the band.

Founded in 1968, Apple Corps predates Apple Inc. by almost a decade, and upon the foundation of what was then called Apple Computer sued the company for the exclusive right to use the Apple name.

The case was settled with an agreement that allowed both companies to use the name on the condition that Apple Computer did not enter the music business, which Apple then proceeded to do in 2001 with the launch of iTunes.

The resulting court battle lasted until 2006 when a judge ruled that Apple Inc.'s use of the name was legitimate. The conclusion of this legal battle paved the way for the Beatles to finally be made available through the iTunes store.

Page 2 of 6
Page 2 of 6
Sky reaches for the Skype

Sky reaches for the Skype

No Man's Sky is not the first time Sky has attempted to flex its muscles over its three letter name.

A high profile win for Sky came in 2013, when it successfully managed to force Microsoft to change the name of its cloud-based drive solution from SkyDrive, which was later renamed OneDrive.

Then in 2015 an EU court ruled that the name of video chat software Skype is too similar to Sky and might cause consumer confusion simply by including the letters 's', 'k' and 'y' next to one another.

For reference, here are some other commonly used words that include the word 'sky': whisky, skyscraper, skydiver, risky and frisky.

To be honest, we're not sold on the judge's reasoning. The BBC quotes the judge as saying, "Conceptually, the figurative element conveys no concept, except perhaps that of a cloud…[That] would further increase the likelihood of the element 'Sky' being recognised within the word element 'Skype', for clouds are to be found 'in the sky' and thus may readily be associated with the word 'sky'."

Thankfully the ruling did not mean that Microsoft was prevented from using the brand-name Skype, it just prevents it from being able to trademark its name and logo.

So it's not so much the practical ramifications of the move as the principal of the thing. Microsoft has continued to use the Skype name to this day, but does so without being fully able to trademark it.

Page 3 of 6
Page 3 of 6
Tim Langdell finds the edge of the law

Tim Langdell finds the edge of the law

Some trademark fights come about because a company has blatantly ripped off the name of another in an attempt to benefit from its brand recognition and power. Others happen because of an entirely coincidental naming similarity that could end up confusing consumers.

And then there's someone like Tim Langdell who seeks to use an old trademark to earn money from companies they have no association to.

In 2009 the game Edge by Mobigame was pulled from the App Store thanks to a copyright claim from Tim Langdell, who claimed to own the rights to the word thanks to his ownership of video game company Edge Games which he founded in 1990.

This was not the first time Langdell had flexed the trademark. Back in 2001 Namco had been prevented from bringing its fighting game Soul Edge to the UK under that name because of the trademark.

But the positive reception Edge had received in the press meant that this trademark claim was the first of Langdell's to get a significant amount of attention in the press.

Things came to a head in 2010 when EA successfully sued Langdell to suspend his exclusive right to the word Edge after its game Mirrror's Edge was claimed to infringe on his trademark.

We should also point out that Langdell was also involved in a court case with TechRadar's owner Future Publishing over the logo of Edge Magazine. Langdell claimed that Future had stolen the logo from his games company, a logo which he claimed to have created in 1991.

When a court finally managed to have a look at the original logo file they found it had been created with Windows 95.

The court ruled in favor of Future.

Page 4 of 6
Page 4 of 6
Batman wipes the slate clean

Batman wipes the slate clean

This one's a little different. It doesn't involve two companies fighting over the use of a name, but instead involves one company suing Warner Bros. over the use of the phrase 'clean slate' in the Batman film 'The Dark Knight Rises'.

That's right, a company alleged that its trademark had been infringed by Batman and Catwoman in the fictional world of Gotham City.

The case was brought by Fortres Grand who make and sell a piece of software called, you guessed it, Clean Slate, which "Restores your computer to its original configuration discarding unwanted computer changes."

For anyone who's interested we actually have a guide on how to reset your pc right here.

So what was Fortres Grand's issue with The Dark Knight Rises? Was it that it was a disappointing sequel to one of the best superhero movies of all time? Was it that Tom Hardy's Bane wasn't a patch on Heath Ledger's Oscar-winning performance as the Joker?

No, it was that the phrase "clean slate" which was used a couple of times throughout the movie by Catwoman to refer to a piece of software that would erase all record of her criminal past.

When the claims were brought to court they were dismissed by the judge who said that "Warner Bros. 'clean slate' software only exists in the fictional world of Gotham; it does not exist in reality. This may seem to be a small point, but it has big ramifications for the consumer confusion analysis, which become apparent once you realize the argument that Fortres Grand has not made – and cannot make."

The judge ruled that in essence this lack of existence of any actual software meant that consumer confusion would be unlikely.

For once, common sense appears to have prevailed in a court.

Page 5 of 6
Page 5 of 6
Microsoft gets off the Metro

Microsoft gets off the Metro

Windows 8 is not high on the list of many people's favourite operating systems. Its touch-focussed user interface felt unnecessary on the desktop, and many of the changes it introduced to the Windows ecosystem felt unintuitive and confusing.

But in court the un-intuitiveness of Microsoft's operating system was the least of its worries. More of a problem was the name of Microsoft's new user interface, Metro, which German retailer Metro AG claimed infringed on its copyright.

What's funny here is not so much the contents of the case since the naming confusion is pretty obvious, but the fact that the Metro name has lived on long after Microsoft has legally had to stop using the name.

While Microsoft has encouraged the adoption of the term "Windows-8-style UI" to replace the trademark infringing Metro, this name has (unsurprisingly) never really caught on, and people continue to use the Metro name to this day.

Now, we wouldn't want to claim that Microsoft has done anything wrong here, but it seems interesting that no catchy alternative to the name Metro has ever been provided.

Some might use that fact to suggest that Microsoft has inadvertently allowed the name to live on despite no longer being able to use it in an official capacity.

Some might suggest that, but not me. Just a good ol' coincidence as far as we're concerned.

Page 6 of 6
Page 6 of 6
Jon Porter
Jon Porter
Social Links Navigation

Jon Porter is the ex-Home Technology Writer for TechRadar. He has also previously written for Practical Photoshop, Trusted Reviews, Inside Higher Ed, Al Bawaba, Gizmodo UK, Genetic Literacy Project, Via Satellite, Real Homes and Plant Services Magazine, and you can now find him writing for The Verge.

Read more
A still of a woman pointing a gun from Grand Theft Auto 6, next to three Nothing CMF Phone 2 Pro phones, next to some Ray-Ban Meta smart glasses
ICYMI: the 8 biggest tech stories of the week, from ChatGPT's shopping upgrade to GTA 6 delays
Apple
This rotten Apple ruling cracks the reality distortion field – and I don't know if that's what consumers want
AI
Meta ‘stole’ my book to train its AI – but there’s a bigger problem
Microsoft
Microsoft hit by new legal claim over restrictive licensing and overcharging allegations
A Symfonisk lamp speaker next to a GTA VI character on a motorbike, and the new Windows Surface tablet.
ICYMI: the week's 7 biggest tech stories, from GTA 6's beautiful new trailer to Sony's WH-1000XM6 headphones teaser
The Xbox Series X Digital next to the new Dyson Airwrap and Nothing Headphone (1)
ICYMI: the week's 7 biggest tech stories from Spotify's suspected AI band to Nothing's first over-ear headphones
Latest in Consoles & PC
Pokémon Legends Z-A
Pokémon Presents returns later this month, hopefully with a new look at Pokémon Legends Z-A ahead of its release date
A PlayStation 5 Pro console with colorful streams of light emanating from its base.
The PS5 lead architect says the PS5 Pro will get an advanced graphics update in 2026 that will deliver better performance
Shadow Labyrinth
Shadow Labyrinth will run at 4K 60fps on Nintendo Switch 2 thanks to a free upgrade
Nintendo Switch 2 overheating
Nintendo Switch 2 owners, beware – some owners are reporting worrisome overheating problems
A screenshot from the game Death Stranding 2: On the Beach
Death Stranding 2: On the Beach sold me on the PS5 Pro, but I'm still not sure I'd recommend the premium console to everyone just yet
Donkey Kong Bananza on Nintendo Switch 2.
Nintendo reveals that Donkey Kong Bananza is developed by the Super Mario Odyssey team – then confirms grass is still green
Latest in News
Intel Core Ultra processor
Windows 11 desktop PCs could soon get Copilot+ AI powers, as Intel might radically switch tactics with next-gen CPUs
Tokyo Game Show 2025 artwork
PlayStation, Square Enix, and more big studios have been confirmed for Tokyo Game Show 2025 - here's what to expect
G.Skill Trident Z Neo DDR4-3600 C16 4x8GB
Rising prices of DDR4, DDR5, GDDR6 RAM set to cause havoc on PC, smartphone and GPU prices - and no, AI is not the one to be blamed
Five characters standing in a room and looking shocked in Blindspot
Netflix might have another Suits-like hit on its hands as unlikely crime thriller makes its way onto the popular streamer's most-watched shows list
Marvel Rivals
Marvel Rivals season 3 is making big changes to how you earn your rewards, but you can claim extra goodies by simply watching your favorite Twitch streamer play the game
Police
UK Police wants to spend $100 million to turn millions of hours of VHS footage into digital format — now that's something AI could help with
LATEST ARTICLES
  1. 1
    Forget AirPods Pro 3 – I think you should grab AirPods Pro 2 for this record-low Prime Day price while you can
  2. 2
    This uber-cute bun-shaped speaker is the best Prime Day Bluetooth speaker deal around and I’m buying several
  3. 3
    6 tips and tricks to get the most out of NordVPN
  4. 4
    'They have a deep love for each other': Foundation season 3 will show you a side of the Cleons you haven't seen before, the Apple TV+ show's cast says
  5. 5
    Done with the noise? You need some cheap Amazon Prime Day noise cancelling headphones deals (thank me later)

TechRadar is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site.

  • About Us
  • Contact Future's experts
  • Contact Us
  • Terms and conditions
  • Privacy policy
  • Cookies policy
  • Advertise with us
  • Web notifications
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Careers

© Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.

Please login or signup to comment

Please wait...