Amazon’s Fire TV Stick isn’t meant to be the company’s top-of-the-line streamer (that title is reserved for the 4K-equipped Amazon Fire TV), but just because you’re buying a budget streaming stick that doesn’t mean you should put up with a sluggish interface and meager selection of apps.
[Update: Amazon has recently updated its premium Amazon Fire TV offering. Whereas this was previously a bulky set-top box, it has now been slimmed down to a convenient dongle without compromising on its 4K output, and bundling in HDR as part of the bargain.
All of this doesn't mean the Fire TV Stick is redundant. It's still an excellent choice if you're using a Full HD 1080p set, but if you've got a 4K TV then you really should get a 4K streaming device such as the Amazon Fire TV, Roku Streaming Stick+ or Chromecast Ultra.]
On those two points, fortunately, the new Amazon Fire TV Stick is mostly a success. Its interface (including its voice search) is incredibly snappy and fast, and it allows access to most of the apps you’d need on a regular basis.
But although the foundations are here for a solid streaming device, it’s a little too inconsistent to be the perfect budget streamer. It’s got a large amount of apps, but omits the major streaming service Now TV, and while its voice search is good, it’s not able to search across every app out there.
It’s a frustrating machine, because when it work as you want it to it’s almost flawless, but these nagging inconsistencies can get in the way.
If you’ve used an Amazon Fire TV Stick in the past then you know what to expect in a physical sense from the new device.
The stick itself measures 85.9 x 30.0 x 12.6mm, and is designed to plug directly into an HDMI port on the back of your TV.
Amazon’s hardware is a little wider than a standard HDMI cable, so in the likely event that it’s too bulky to plug directly into the HDMI port, Amazon also includes a short male-to-female HDMI cable to help it fit.
On the side of the stick is a micro USB port for powering the device. If you’ve got a newer TV then there’s a good chance it’ll have a USB port on the back for powering such devices, but if not Amazon also includes a power adaptor in the box, and the supplied USB cable should be more than long enough to reach your power strip.
Internally the device has seen a bit of an upgrade over the previous generation of Fire TV Stick. Its Wi-Fi has been upgraded from 802.11n to the faster 802.11ac standard, which should allow content to buffer as quickly as possible. Its CPU has jumped from a dual-core to a quad-core, Dolby support has jumped to 5.1, and the Bluetooth version has gone up from 3.0 to 4.1.
Unfortunately the one spec you’re likely to care the most about, resolution, has seen no change between the previous generation of the Fire TV Stick and this one. It’s still a 1080p, non-HDR streaming stick, despite Google’s proving that the dongle form factor is able to handle 4K just fine. If you want a streamer that’s able to handle 4K with the Amazon name on it, then you’re going to have to opt for the more premium .
The remote is where we find the biggest change with this version of the Amazon Fire TV Stick. The bottom six buttons are exactly the same as on the previous remote, as is the four-way nav pad which allows you to navigate the device’s menus.
What’s changed is the addition of a voice control button, which you hold down to summon Alexa, which in theory makes up for the simplicity of the remote by allowing you to search for the exact show that you want without having to type using an on-screen keyboard.
However in practice its functionality is limited, something we’ll get into more in the performance section below.
You also have the option of using the Fire TV remote on a smart device, which has the benefit of offering an on-screen keyboard that’s much faster than using the remote to type. Annoyingly, though, this keyboard is limited to apps which use Amazon’s own keyboard.
This means that for an app like BBC iPlayer, which has its own keyboard built into the software, you won’t be able to use the app’s on-screen keyboard – instead you’ll be forced to laboriously navigate the keyboard on your television screen use the remote.
The selection of apps, in the UK at least, is fairly decent. Catch-up services from each of the major broadcasters are present (including UKTV), as are Netflix and Amazon Prime Instant Video (naturally). The one major omission from a UK perspective is Now TV, which is all that prevents the Amazon Fire TV stick from having a full suite of software.
For customers in the US there are even more options like Hulu, Sling TV and DISH's new DISH Now service that lets you stream content from your Hopper to your Amazon Fire TV wherever you are in the world.
The Amazon Fire TV Stick is a speedy piece of hardware. Scrolling through menus is delightfully quick, and once you find something you want to watch it loads almost instantly (depending, naturally, on the speed of your internet connection).
The Amazon Fire TV Stick’s user interface is laid out in a straightforward way. Recently accessed shows and apps can be found on the home screen, or you can scroll up and across to find different content and apps.
Annoyingly, for many apps you can’t access their content directly from the home screen; you’ll have to navigate to the app first, and then find content within the app.
The result is that finding what you want to watch may take you a little longer depending on which platform it’s on, especially if you’re making use of the Fire TV Stick’s search functionality.
If it’s on one of the platforms supported by Amazon’s universal search (Amazon Prime and Netflix being the two main examples) then you’re laughing. You have two options here. Either you head up and left on the main menu to reach the search box, and enter the TV show or film name on the on-screen keyboard, or you can simply hold down the voice search button on the remote and say the name of the content you’d like to watch.
If you’ve ever used Alexa on an then you’ll know it’s a very accurate piece of voice recognition software. It was able to understand what show we were looking for almost every time, and on the one occasion it didn’t it presented two options for us to choose from on the screen.
However, the unfortunate fact is that a lot of the streaming services on the Fire Stick aren’t covered by this universal search functionality, and this makes their content much harder to find.
Search for a show that’s only available through the BBC iPlayer for instance, and Amazon’s software will have absolutely nothing to show you. It’s not even intelligent enough to know which streaming service the show is available on.
Instead you’ll have to navigate to the app in question (which can be done using voice search), open it, and manually find the program via the app’s own interface – and here you won’t be able to use Alexa to search, so you’ll have to navigate an on-screen keyboard using your remote.
The search function, including Alexa, is more or less limited to searching for program titles, despite the steps Amazon has taken with its X-ray functionality, which allows you to access IMDB information within its shows.
Search for ‘Jeremy Clarkson’ for example, and rather than bringing up Amazon’s flagship show, The Grand Tour, you’re instead confusingly given a link to the TV show Dexter of all things.
Although Amazon’s search functionality is fast and accurate, it only covers a fraction of the content you’re likely to be streaming, and it’s not nearly as clever or as capable as Alexa on the Echo.
Alexa is also under-utilised when it comes to controlling the playback of content. You’re able to skip ahead to the next episode using your voice, but you’re not able to skip back an episode – and if you’re watching a series on anything other than Amazon Prime then you won’t even be able to skip forward.
The Amazon Fire TV Stick’s interface is quick and snappy. It’s intuitively laid out, and finding most content is quick and easy.
Once you get to your content it streams without any complaints or buffering. Playback is smooth and good-looking.
The voice search functionality is quick and accurate when searching for Amazon or Netflix content, and it’s also a speedy way of hopping between apps. Most major streaming services are supported.
Although you can access Amazon and Netflix content from the home screen or search results directly, most other apps require you to launch the app in question first and then navigate to its content. This limits the usefulness of the device’s search functionality, especially its excellent Alexa voice recognition search.
Alexa is also under-utilised when it comes to controlling playback. You can use it to skip to the next episode, but you can’t skip backwards, and nor can you jump to a particular episode.
Resolution is limited to 1080p, although this is perhaps understandable given that this is a budget-focused device.
Being able to use the Fire TV app to enter text is useful, but the amount of situations in which this actually works is very limited.
The Amazon Fire TV Stick with Alexa Voice Remote feels like a missed opportunity. There’s so much functionality here that should make the device easier to use, but which ultimately only ends up being of benefit for Amazon’s own video content.
If you’re watching Amazon or Netflix content then the interface is a dream. It’s quick, voice search works well, and it’s easy to find what you want to watch.
Venture into more niche streaming services, however, and the stick’s functionality is much more basic, offering merely a portal to each app’s own interface rather than functionality of its own.
This is a solid piece of streaming hardware, but it’s not the step forward we hoped Alexa might have enabled it to be.