I just tested the cheapest 17-inch gaming laptop with an RTX 5070 GPU I've seen so far — and I'm amazed by the power and performance for the price

A budget powerhouse?

Medion Erazer Defender 17 P10
Great Value
(Image credit: © Future)

TechRadar Verdict

Medion’s Erazer Defender 17 P10 condenses a formidable spec into a reasonably priced package. It’s clear that corners have been cut with the less-than-premium body and poor battery life, but ultimately the Erazer Defender 17 P10 focuses its efforts on what gamers want most, and it largely succeeds on that front.

Reasons to buy

  • +

    Well-priced for the spec

  • +

    Impressive cooling abilities

  • +

    Vibrant display

Reasons to avoid

  • -

    Cut-price design

  • -

    Persistent fan noise

  • -

    Poor battery life

Why you can trust TechRadar We spend hours testing every product or service we review, so you can be sure you're buying the best. Find out more about how we test.

Medion Erazer Defender 17 P10: Two-minute review

The Erazer Defender 17 P10 is a large and powerful gaming laptop with a price tag one could consider ‘budget’ when judging it against its rivals.

It doesn’t look particularly exciting or stylish. There are a few discreet elements that evoke a gaming focus, but otherwise the P10’s design is purely functional. It doesn’t employ the most premium of materials, either, though the whole unit is reassuringly solid, save for the keyboard, which flexes considerably when you use it. And while it’s hardly the most portable device, there are worse 17-inch gaming machines to carry around.

One of the benefits of this large size, though, is the space available for ports. On the rear of the Erazer Defender 17 P10 there are power, HDMI, and Ethernet connections, as well as a USB-C port that supports DisplayPort 1.4. On the right is another USB-C port that also supports DisplayPort 1.4, as well as Power Delivery. Two USB-A ports are featured on both sides, too, and the left side also gets a headset jack.

Latest Videos FromTechRadar

When it comes to the business of gaming, the Erazer Defender 17 P10 is very capable. It managed to run various AAA titles at very high frame rates — above 60fps in many cases — with demanding graphics settings applied. More impressive is its cooling, although the price paid for this is persistent, if innocuous, fan noise.

Medion Erazer Defender 17 P10

(Image credit: Future)

Despite its unspectacular 1080p resolution and lack of OLED tech (although this is a rarity for gaming laptops at this price point), the display also impressed me. Its vibrancy shows off games and other content in all their glory, and while its resolution isn’t the sharpest, it’s sharp enough to provide sufficient fidelity across the 17-inch real estate.

The keyboard is great to use for both gaming and typing, thanks to the snappy and low-traveling — yet tactile — keys. That aforementioned flexing feels a little strange at first, but it actually provides cushioning and dampening, helping to nullify the harshness of furious presses. The touchpad is equally capable, thanks to its smooth surface, responsiveness, and large surface area.

The battery life is on par for what you would expect of a gaming laptop — which is to say it’s not great. It lasted five and a half hours in our movie playback test, which is 40 minutes better than what the Medion Erazer Major 16 X1 achieved, although less than half the time posted by the Asus V16, a much cheaper gaming laptop.

This aspect aside, though, the Erazer Defender 17 P10 is a strong performer with a welcome price tag relative to its spec. You’ll have to settle for an unspectacular design and a poor battery life, but if you think these aspects are worth sacrificing for gaming prowess, then the Erazer Defender 17 P10 represents good value in the large gaming laptop sector.

Medion Erazer Defender 17 P10

(Image credit: Future)

Medion Erazer Defender 17 P10 review: Price & availability

  • Starts from £1,649.99 (about $2,200 / AU$3,150)
  • Available now in the UK only
  • Reasonable price for the spec

The P10 starts from £1,649.99 (about $2,200 / AU$3,150) and is available in the UK only. The base model features an Intel Core i9-14900HX, an Nvidia GeForce RTX 5060, 16GB of RAM, and 1TB of storage. The higher-spec model costs £1,899.97 (about $2,500 / AU$3,600), and gets an RTX 5070 and 32GB of RAM.

This is a reasonable price when you compare the Erazer Defender 17 P10 to other gaming laptops of a similar spec and size. There are a few budget offerings that rival its value for money, though: one of them is another Erazer model, the Major 16 X1. This is more expensive than the top P10 model, but its spec is better across the board, with its Intel Core Ultra 9, RTX 5070 Ti, 32GB of RAM, and 2TB of storage, not to mention its much sharper — but inch smaller — 1600p display.

There’s also the Asus V16 for bargain hunters to consider, which we rate as one of the best budget gaming laptop picks around. This is much cheaper than any Erazer Defender 17 P10 model, but you’ll have to settle for a 40-series RTX, and it too has a smaller 16-inch display.

Medion Erazer Defender 17 P10 review: Specs

Swipe to scroll horizontally
Row 0 - Cell 0

Medion Erazer Defender 17 P10 base spec

Medion Erazer Defender 17 P10 review spec

Price

£1,649.99 (about $2,200 / AU$3,150)

£1,899.97 (about $2,500 / AU$3,600)

CPU

Intel Core i9-14900HX (up to 5.8GHz, 24 cores)

Intel Core i9-14900HX (up to 5.8GHz, 24 cores)

Graphics

NVIDIA GeForce RTX 5060 Laptop GPU (8GB GDDR7)

NVIDIA GeForce RTX 5070 Laptop GPU (8GB GDDR7)

RAM

16GB DDR5

32GB DDR5

Screen

17.3-inch HD (1920 x 1080) IPS LCD, 16:9, 144Hz

17.3-inch HD (1920 x 1080) IPS LCD, 16:9, 144Hz

Storage

1TB PCIe 4.0 NVMe M.2

1TB PCIe 4.0 NVMe M.2

Ports

1x power adapter, 2x USB-C (1x 3.2 Gen 2 (DisplayPort / Power Delivery), 1x 3.2 Gen 2 (DisplayPort)), 2x USB-A (1x 3.2 Gen 2, 1x 3.2 Gen 1), 1x HDMI, 1x RJ-45, 1x 3.5mm combo audio

1x power adapter, 2x USB-C (1x 3.2 Gen 2 (DisplayPort / Power Delivery), 1x 3.2 Gen 2 (DisplayPort)), 2x USB-A (1x 3.2 Gen 2, 1x 3.2 Gen 1), 1x HDMI, 1x RJ-45, 1x 3.5mm combo audio

Wireless

Wi-Fi 6E, Bluetooth 5.3

Wi-Fi 6E, Bluetooth 5.3

Battery

53Wh

53Wh

Weight

6 lbs / 2.7kg

6 lbs / 2.7kg

Dimensions

15.63 x 11.26 x 1.04 inches / 397 x 286 x 26.5mm

15.63 x 11.26 x 1.04 inches / 397 x 286 x 26.5mm

Medion Erazer Defender 17 P10

(Image credit: Future)

Medion Erazer Defender 17 P10 review: Design & features

  • Functional design
  • Solid build
  • Plenty of ports

The Erazer Defender 17 P10 has a basic appearance with little fanfare. About the only concessions to style are the RGB keyboard and some gamer-esque cuts and angles around the vents. For the most part, though, this is a utilitarian piece of laptop design.

While the materials employed aren’t the most premium, the unit is mostly solid, aside from the flexing on the keyboard. And I certainly welcomed the smoothness of the keyboard enclosure when resting my wrists on it.

Thankfully, the keys are of a higher quality, featuring a subtle texturing and a fetching floating design. As always, I’m glad to see a full-size layout on a laptop, although I would expect nothing less from a 17-inch device.

Medion Erazer Defender 17 P10

(Image credit: Future)

There are some useful Fn shortcuts on the Function row, and both they and all the other keys can be reprogrammed using the preinstalled Control Center utility software. Granted, this is limited to macro recording with the keys already on the board — far more spartan compared to the best gaming keyboard software — but it’s uncommon to see any such software for laptop keyboards.

As you might expect from a 17-inch gaming laptop, the Erazer Defender 17 P10 isn’t exactly the most portable device in the world. However, it’s just about light and thin enough to stuff into a backpack.

Another more positive expectation you may have from such a machine is a large number of ports, and thankfully the Erazer Defender 17 P10 meets this too. At the back, you’ll find the power adapter socket, flanked on both sides by an Ethernet port, an HDMI port, and a USB-C port that supports the DisplayPort 1.4 standard — practical locations for such connections.

On the right are two USB ports: one type-A and the other type-C. The latter again supports the DisplayPort 1.4 standard, but with additional Power Delivery support. On the left is another USB-A port and a 3.5mm headset jack. All these side ports are all placed further forward than is typical, which might be a problem for those who don’t like cables protruding from the middle of their laptop.

Medion Erazer Defender 17 P10

(Image credit: Future)

Medion Erazer Defender 17 P10 review: Performance

  • Very capable gaming performance
  • Fans are loud but provide great cooling
  • Keyboard good for gaming and typing

The performance of the Erazer Defender 17 P10 is impressive. I managed to get 60-70fps when I played Cyberpunk 2077 on the Ray Tracing: Low preset, and it even did an admirable job of handling Ray Tracing: Ultra, giving me around 40 fps, although drops into the thirties and below occurred during more chaotic scenes.

In order to handle this kind of intensity, the fans fire up at the slightest provocation when they’re set to the Performance mode. But while the noise is certainly noticeable and near-constant, I didn’t find its tone harsh. What’s more, they do a very admirable job of keeping the Erazer Defender 17 P10 cool at all times; no doubt this is also thanks to the large vents on the sides, back, and underneath, as well as the sheer size of the unit itself helping to dissipate heat.

Content looks surprisingly sharp on the P10, given the large 17-inch real estate is only given a 1080p resolution to work with, although some loss in fidelity is apparent. It’s also pleasingly vibrant and has acceptable levels of contrast, despite lacking OLED technology. It can be reflective, especially when displaying darker scenes, but in the main the brightness levels are sufficient to maintain good visibility.

Medion Erazer Defender 17 P10

(Image credit: Future)

Whether you’re gaming or working, the Erazer Defender 17 P10’s keyboard is up to the task. The keys are very light and snappy with a low travel, while at the same time providing good tactility. This makes them great for rapid yet controlled spamming, as well as typing.

Their generous spacing also helps with the latter, and compensates for their oddly narrow form. That aforementioned flexing is a blessing, too, as it acts to cushion presses in the absence of dampening materials underneath the keys. I found this a little disconcerting at first, but after I adjusted, I found it to be a boon.

When my fingers were on the WASD keys, I did find the space bar a little too short to use optimally with my thumb. This is a minor gripe, though, and mostly I found it comfortable to game in this position.

The touchpad is also easy to use, thanks to its smooth surface and responsiveness, although there were times when taps failed to register. It’s also large enough to facilitate easy navigation, but can occasionally get in the way while typing; I found that initial contact with my palm would trigger it, but further contact after that would be blocked.

Medion Erazer Defender 17 P10

(Image credit: Future)

Medion Erazer Defender 17 P10 review: Battery life

  • Poor battery life
  • In line with other gaming laptops
  • Reasonably quick to charge

As is the case with many large gaming laptops, the Erazer Defender 17 P10 has a short battery life. It lasted five and a half hours when I ran a movie on a continuous loop, which makes it more enduring than the Erazer Major 16 X1, but only by 40 minutes.

However, it’s a lot shorter-lived than the Asus V16, which is something of an outlier in the sector and lasted close to 13 hours in the same test. The Erazer Defender 17 P10 is at least quick to charge, though, taking between an hour and 90 minutes to fully replenish.

Should I buy the Medion Erazer Defender 17 P10?

Scorecard

Swipe to scroll horizontally

Attributes

Notes

Rating

Value

The Erazer Defender 17 P10 is good value for such a large laptop with a powerful spec.

4 / 5

Design & features

It mightn’t be the most exciting to look at, but it’s built well enough. It’s not exactly portable, but there are worse 17-inch laptops to travel with.

4 / 5

Performance

Gaming at high frame rates is certainly possible, and while the fans can fire up at the drop of a hat, their cooling abilities are impressive.

4 / 5

Battery life

Longevity is in line with many large gaming laptops. There are a few that can outlast it, though.

3.5 / 5

Overall Rating

The Erazer Defender 17 P10 is a good proposition if you’re in the market for a large and powerful gaming laptop without spending untold amounts. You won’t be getting a premium design or great battery life, but in other regards the Erazer Defender 17 P10 is a fine machine.

4 / 5

Buy it if…

You want good value
You won’t find many large gaming laptops with such a capable spec for less.

You want a good non-OLED display
Content is surprisingly vibrant with good levels of contrast, while the 1080p resolution is just sharp enough for the 17-inch size.

Don't buy it if…

You want the best design
In terms of looks and material quality, the Erazer Defender 17 P10 is unlikely to wow you.

You want the best portability
A 17-inch gaming laptop is never going to be easy to carry around, and although the Erazer Defender 17 P10 does well to keep its weight and dimensions down, it’s still a chore to lug around.

Medion Erazer Defender 17 P10 review: Also consider

Medion Erazer Major 16 X1
The Erazer Major 16 X1 is more expensive than the Erazer Defender 17 P10, but it’s still good value when you consider its spec is better in just about every way. This includes its display resolution, which is much sharper at 1600p, although it’s smaller at 16 inches. Read our full Medion Erazer Major 16 X1 review.

Asus V16
The V16 is much cheaper than the Erazer Defender 17 P10, although its overall spec is weaker: most notably when it comes to its RTX 4050 GPU. However, it has the same 1080p resolution, and is surprisingly portable for a large gaming laptop. Read our full Asus V16 review.

Medion Erazer Defender 17 P10

(Image credit: Future)

How I tested the Medion Erazer Defender 17 P10

  • Tested for a couple of days
  • Used for gaming and ran benchmarks
  • Plentiful gaming laptop experience

I tested the Erazer Defender 17 P10 for a few days, gaming with it as well as using it for working and streaming video content.

I ran our series of benchmark tests, designed to assess every facet of a gaming laptop’s performance. I also ran a movie on a continuous loop to test its battery life.

I’ve been PC gaming for over a decade, and have used a variety of builds and components in that time. I’ve also reviewed numerous gaming laptops before, across all shapes, sizes, specs, and budgets.

Lewis Maddison
Reviews Writer

Lewis Maddison is a Reviews Writer for TechRadar. He previously worked as a Staff Writer for our business section, TechRadar Pro, where he gained experience with productivity-enhancing hardware, ranging from keyboards to standing desks. His area of expertise lies in computer peripherals and audio hardware, having spent over a decade exploring the murky depths of both PC building and music production. He also revels in picking up on the finest details and niggles that ultimately make a big difference to the user experience.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.