MacBook Pro M4 vs iMac M4: which Mac is best for you?

In the ever-evolving world of Apple devices, selecting the right machine for your needs can be exciting and overwhelming. Two of Apple's standout offerings, the 2024 MacBook Pro with the M4 chip and the 2024 iMac with the M4 chip, present a compelling choice for those seeking power and performance.

Both devices benefit from the impressive capabilities of Apple silicon, but their distinct designs and features cater to different priorities.

This article compares these two machines, examining their strengths and weaknesses across key areas such as performance, display, portability, connectivity, and upgradeability. The goal is to help you make an informed decision.

MacBook Pro M4 vs iMac M4: Specs

MacBook Pro M4 vs iMac M4: Prices & availability

The MacBook Pro (2024) was released in 2024 and has since been superseded by the M5-powered models - although it's not an essential to upgrade, given how good the M4 chip is even now.

The laptop is available in two display sizes: 14 inches and 16 inches. The 14-inch model offers an entry-level M4 chip or a mid-range M4 Pro chip. The 16-inch model has either the M4 Pro or the M4 Max chip. Additionally, all models allow you to customize RAM and storage options.

Prices start from around $2000 / £2000 depending on which machine you choose. For comparison, the latest M5 models are priced from $1699 in the US and from £1699 in the UK, with the 16-inch models running from $2699 / £2699.

The iMac is offered in four configurations. Only the base model features an M4 chip with an 8-core CPU and an 8-core GPU. The other three models are equipped with an M4 chip that has a 10-core CPU and a 10-core GPU.

Prices start from $1299 direct from Apple in the US, while in the UK, it costs from £1299 at Apple.

MacBook Pro M4 vs iMac M4: Portability

Regarding portability, the MacBook Pro M4 is the clear winner. Designed for mobility, this laptop allows you to take it to work, school quickly or anywhere else you need. In contrast, the iMac M4 is an all-in-one desktop computer.

While its slim design is aesthetically pleasing, it is meant to stay in one place. You won’t be able to pack it in a backpack or take it on a plane. If portability is a priority for you, the MacBook Pro is the best choice.

However, the iMac is an excellent option if you need a stationary machine with a larger screen and are willing to sacrifice portability.

Winner: Of course it's the MacBook Pro

MacBook Pro M4 vs iMac M4: Performance

The MacBook Pro M4 and iMac M4 feature Apple's impressive M4 chip, but the two have minor performance differences. The iMac M4 has a base 8-core CPU and 8-core GPU, whereas the MacBook Pro M4 has a more powerful 10-core CPU and 10-core GPU. This gives the MacBook Pro an advantage in graphics-intensive tasks like video editing and gaming.

However, the MacBook Pro and the iMac can be configured with up to 24GB of unified memory. This extra memory can significantly enhance performance for demanding workflows that involve multitasking and memory-intensive applications.

Winner: At the base model level, the MacBook Pro. Otherwise, it's a tie.

MacBook Pro M4 vs iMac M4: Display

It's important to note some significant differences between the MacBook Pro M4 displays and the iMac M4. The MacBook Pro features a smaller 14.2-inch Liquid Retina XDR display with a higher resolution of 3024 x 1964 and a superior refresh rate of up to 120Hz, thanks to ProMotion technology. This results in smoother scrolling, more responsive animations, and a more fluid visual experience overall.

In contrast, the iMac M4 has a larger 24-inch Retina 4.5K display with a resolution of 4480 x 2520, but it only offers a standard refresh rate of 60Hz. While the iMac's display is still sharp and vibrant, it does not include ProMotion technology or the high refresh rate found in the MacBook Pro.

Ultimately, the best display for you depends on your preferences. The iMac has an advantage if you prioritize a larger screen with sharp visuals. However, the MacBook Pro's display is the better choice if you value a smoother, more responsive experience and portability.

Winner: For size, the iMac

MacBook Pro M4 vs iMac M4: Upgradeability

Both the iMac M4 and the MacBook Pro M4 have significant limitations regarding upgradeability. Neither device allows user upgrades to the processor or graphics, as these components are integrated into the M4 chip. This means you must select your desired specifications at the time of purchase.

Memory upgrades are also impossible on either machine, as the RAM is soldered directly to the motherboard. This means you are locked into the amount of memory you initially choose.

The only component of the iMac M4 that might be user-upgradeable in some configurations is the storage. However, Apple does not officially support this process, and it can be pretty complex, potentially voiding the warranty.

In summary, the iMac M4 and MacBook Pro M4 offer limited upgradeability. Before purchasing, consider your needs for processing power, graphics performance, and memory; upgrading these components later will not be straightforward.

Winner: iMac

MacBook Pro M4 vs iMac M4: Connectivity

The iMac M4 and MacBook Pro M4 have notable differences in connectivity. The MacBook Pro M4 offers a consistent array of ports across all configurations: three Thunderbolt 4 ports, an HDMI port, an SDXC card slot, and a headphone jack. This provides a comprehensive range of options for connecting displays, peripherals, and storage devices.

In contrast, the iMac M4 comes in two different configurations. The base model is limited to just two Thunderbolt/USB 4 ports, which may not be sufficient for some users. To enjoy a more extensive range of connectivity options—featuring four Thunderbolt/USB 4 ports, Gigabit Ethernet, and a Magic Keyboard with Touch ID—you must choose the higher-priced configuration.

While both machines offer modern and fast connectivity options, the MacBook Pro provides a more consistent and versatile set of ports from the start.

Winner: MacBook Pro

MacBook Pro M4 vs iMac M4: Verdict

The 2024 MacBook Pro M4 and iMac M4, powered by the same Apple silicon, provide distinct experiences tailored to different needs. A key differentiator is portability; the MacBook Pro is designed for mobility, while the iMac is a stationary desktop. In terms of performance, the MacBook Pro generally has a slight advantage due to its standard 10-core GPU and higher maximum memory configuration, although the iMac features greater memory bandwidth.

Regarding displays, the MacBook Pro boasts a 14.2-inch Liquid Retina XDR display with ProMotion technology, offering a smoother and more responsive visual experience. In contrast, the iMac features a 24-inch Retina 4.5K display, which provides more screen real estate.

Neither machine allows for user upgrades to the processor, graphics, or memory. Regarding connectivity, the MacBook Pro offers a consistent set of ports across all its configurations, while the iMac M4 comes in two configurations with varying port options. Choosing between these devices depends on whether you prioritize portability and an exceptional display experience (MacBook Pro) or a larger screen with an all-in-one design (iMac).

Most folks would probably get more use out of the MacBook Pro, although you are likely to pay more.

Winner: MacBook Pro