Updated 11 hours ago

Google TV review

Can Google's Internet TV service deliver the experience you demand?

Our Score 3

Last reviewed: 2011-01-19January 19th 2011

google-tv-review

Can Google TV live up to expectations?

Despite asking its hardware partners not to show new Google TV devices at CES, Google has said that this is the year that Google TV will be available outside the US.

But if the first international Google TV devices are like the $300 Logitech Revue that's currently shipping in the US, will you want one when you can buy it?

The idea behind Google TV is to take the TV screen and the TV channels you already have and add the web, complete with Flash and HTML 5, web content like YouTube and a search interface that brings it all together.

What you get is an interface running on top of a derivative of Android 2.1 plus Chrome rather than the Android browser - but still with Flash 10.1 built in.

google tv

That's all running on an Intel Atom CE4150 processor with hardware accelerated video encoding and decoding (for H.264 but not for WebM) rather than the ARM processor we're used to seeing Android on. And that means that not only is the Revue's case large enough to fit in a full set of connectors – HDMI in, HDMI out, Ethernet, two USB ports, two IR blaster ports and SPDIF – it also has air vents and a fan (although you won't notice it over the sound of your TV).

Most add-on media streaming boxes that you plug into your TV, like Apple TV and Boxee systems, leave you to control your TV separately, with its original remote.

Google TV is more like Windows Media Centre (or the Windows Media Center-based set-top boxes that will be out this year), where you get one remote control for working with both TV and online content, and you can see TV shows (from a cable TV or set-top box but not broadcast channels, at least on the systems we tested) full screen or in a picture-in-picture window, via the HDMI port.

logitech revue

The Revue has the advantage of Logitech's Harmony remote technology; tell it the model of your TV, set-top box or AV receiver (easier said than done if you've got a flatscreen mounted on the wall) and it looks them up in its online database and lets you control them from the Revue remote.

It's limited to controlling three IR devices, but it does mean you only have one remote to find space for. But that remote is actually a full size QWERTY keyboard, which is going to put off a number of mainstream users straight away.

Your comments (2) Click to add a new comment

marybranscombe


January 21st 2011

2. @bradavon - I suspect that Google isn't set up to make the partnerships with cable providers that a combined box would need (and neither are Sony, Logitech or Samsung - that takes someone like Pace, Amstrad and their US equivalents), and yes, unless things change you'll need a set-top box/PVR as well as Google TV if you want actual TV. But that PVR will come with its own remote that you can still use to change channel ;-)

Alert a moderator

bradavon


January 19th 2011

1. A keyboard AND remote is essential. Having to use a cumbersome keyboard just to go to the next channel would annoy me rotten.

Why on earth isn't a cable stb included? This should be able to replace a cable stb, not run alongside it. The same goes for Freeview when it reaches the UK.

If I had to own a Freeview HD PVR + Google TV I know for certain I wouldn't bother.

Alert a moderator

Tell us what you think

You need to Log in or register to post comments

By submitting this form you agree to our Terms of Use and so are legally responsible for anything you submit. DO NOT submit anything which may violate the Terms of Use or another person's rights including copyrighted or offensive materials.

Product Summary

Google TV

google tv review

Best Price

Unavailable

For

>

It's the internet on your TV

>

QWERTY keyboard

>

Full web with HTML5 and Flash

>

YouTube works well

Against

>

Overly complicated

>

Limited content

>

Full-screen takes an extra click

>

Few websites work well from 10 feet away

>

Feels like a beta product

The Toshiba 55ZL2 is the first 4K consumer TV announced. It uses the extra resolution to create glasses-free 3D

4K TV resolution: what you need to know

What is 4K, why is it significant and when can you get it?

Which is the best projector for you?

Best projector: 14 best in the UK today

Find the best projector for you with this handy guide

There's a good sound bar for any TV and any budget

10 best soundbar speakers for your HD TV

10 super soundbars to give your flat telly some sound welly

Recommended for you