Sigma SD1 Merrill review

Now a fraction of its original price, but is a revolutionary sensor enough?

TODO alt text

So does the Sigma SD1 Merrill's fabled Foveon X3 sensor make a difference? At low ISO sensitivities, absolutely. With careful raw processing there's lots of fine detail to bring out, colours are rich and images have an overall smooth and silky, film-like quality that's impressive.

However, edge towards ISO 1600 - a mid-range setting in the post-Nikon D3 world - and the Sigma SD1 Merrill's firm grip on image quality loosens. Noise is a significant problem, creeping in at even lower sensitivities with JPEGs.

The Sigma SD1 Merrill's .X3F raw files do fare a little better, but currently you can't process these in mainstream software such as Adobe Camera Raw. Instead, they need to be converted in Sigma Photo Pro - a painfully underpowered and slow-performing slab of software.

Sigma SD1 Merrill review

This is a shame, because to get the best from the Sigma SD1 Merrill, raw files are in order. JPEGs straight out of the camera just look flat and unremarkable.

Carefully processed raw files do have the potential to look excellent, though. The 23.5 x 15.7mm 46MP (or rather, 15.4MP x3) sensor is no match for the larger 44mm x 33mm 40MP sensor in the Pentax 645D but, thankfully, the much cheaper price reflects this.

The Sigma SD1 Merrill can certainly deliver pictures with excellent dynamic range that give more expensive full-frame cameras a run for their money, at lower sensitivities at least.

Sigma SD1 Merrill review

Other areas of performance are a mixed bag. Auto White Balance errs towards the cool side, but focusing is quick and (most of the time) accurate. Exposure is also an area that requires regular manual intervention.

Like Canon's iFCL metering system, the Sigma SD1 Merrill's evaluative metering pattern seems to weight the exposure reading to the active focus point. This can lead to exposures that are too dark or too light, depending on which AF point is highlighted. Admittedly, if you use the camera for significant periods you grow accustomed to the metering system's nuances, and can compensate as a result.

Tech Specs

Product TypeDigital SLR Camera Body Only
Battery Size SupportedProprietary Battery Size
Wireless LANNo
Effective Camera Resolution46 Megapixel
Memory Card SupportedCompactFlash (CF) Card
Image StabilizationNo
Digital ZoomNo
Brand NameSigma
DurabilityWeather Proof, Splash Proof
FeaturesContinuous Shooting Mode, Self-timer
Screen Size7.6 cm (3")
Viewfinder TypeSLR
Weight (Approximate)700 g
Image Sensor Size23.50 mm x 15.70 mm
Maximum Image Resolution4704 x 3136
Display Screen TypeLCD
Height113.5 mm
Width145.5 mm
Depth80 mm
Image FormatsJPEG, RAW, TIFF
External FlashOptional
Focus ModesAuto, Manual
ManufacturerSigma Corporation
Product ModelSD1
Product NameSD1 Merrill Digital SLR Camera
Exposure Control
  • (P) Program AE
  • (S) Shutter Speed Priority AE
  • (A) Aperture Priority AE
  • (M) Manual
Manufacturer Part NumberC26900
Manufacturer Website Address
Marketing Information

This truly groundbreaking digital SLR camera incorporates a 46 megapixel (4,800x3,200x3 layers) 24x16mm APS-C X3 direct image sensor. The SD1 is Sigma's flagship digital SLR model housed in a solid magnesium alloy body making it extremely lightweight with an overall nice feel and pleasant handling. The splash proof feature protects the camera from the effects of harsh weather conditions. Incorporating a 24x16mm APS-C X3 direct image sensor, dual "TRUE (Three-layer Responsive Ultimate Engine) II" image processing engines and the 46 megapixel sensor ensures that high resolution images are processed quickly with high definition and a smooth and subtle graduation of color delivering an image size of approximately 35/45 mp in raw/tiff files. This latest technology meets the strictest standards and requirements of professionals and enthusiast photographers for all types of photography.