Ethical electronics: how Apple, Intel and more are stamping out conflict minerals

Conflict-free sourcing

Apple, along with Acer, BT, Cisco, Dell, Foxconn, HP, Huawei, Lenovo, Microsoft, Sony and nearly 150 other technology firms, is a member of the Conflict-Free Sourcing Initiative (CFSi), an EICC project that has identified and audited conflict-free smelters for all four conflict minerals.

Program director Michael Rohwer calls it "a major milestone in the global effort to support an end to the conflict in the Democratic Republic of the Congo," while Sasha Lezhnev, senior Congo policy analyst with the anti-genocide ENOUGH Project, says that "having conflict-free smelters now available for all four conflict minerals is a tremendous achievement we've all been waiting for for years.

It means that electronics, aerospace and other companies can make informed choices on their supplier decisions… and it is critical that more and more companies begin doing so."

Child labour

Many minerals are mined by children. The profits often help fund bloodshed. [Credit: ENOUGH Project]

There's more to it than just identifying smelters, though. As Apple's Williams told the FT, while channeling demand through a few verified smelters would enable Apple to "wave our conflict-free flag," such a move "would do nothing to affect the workers on the ground".

Apple, like other electronics giants, believes that the solution is to get "a critical mass of suppliers verified so that we can truly influence the demand situation and change things".

Mbubi believes that Apple's naming and shaming policy, which highlights suppliers who refuse to be audited, is "courageous". "It is encouraging to see this disclosure taking place as it increases transparency in the smelting industry."

Laws and lobbyists

In the US, the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection legislation compels firms to report their use of conflict minerals.

As Mark Morley, director of industry marketing for supply chain experts GXS, explains: "The law means that any company submitting filings to the [US] Securities and Exchange Commission must confirm there are no conflict minerals in their supply chain."

Inevitably, some firms don't like that. The US Chamber of Commerce, the Business Roundtable and the National Association of Manufacturers are asking judges to overturn that requirement on the grounds that the reporting imposes unfair costs and infringes their right to free speech by "forcing them to condemn their own products".

According to Judge A Raymond Randolph: "there seems to be a slippery slope problem here… could Congress say that all companies now have to report the conditions under which their products are manufactured overseas, what the pay rate is, whether they are using child labour?"

Human rights activists are worried about this. Most firms aren't like the big-name tech firms who care as much about their brand image as their bottom line.

If the legal challenge is successful and firms aren't forced to disclose their use of conflict minerals, activists believe, then firms might not clean up their act. "If legal challenges to the Dodd-Frank Act go through," Mbubi says, "this will pose a serious risk of big firms continuing to line warlords' pockets."

Cleaning up

Intel has made a difference in a very short period of time - it started attempting to clean up the supply of tantalum in 2009, and by 2012 unaudited tantalum smelters were finding it difficult to sell their products. An issue that wasn't on most people's radar a few years ago now makes big headlines worldwide.

Organisations such as Congo Calling hope that conflict minerals will soon be as unacceptable as blood diamonds. "We, the end users, should continue to demand our electronics companies source their materials ethically," Mbubi says.

"We should start buying our electronic products based on ethical choices as they become available."

Lobbyists may try to neuter legislation such as the Dodd-Frank Act, but they can't stop us from voting with our wallets.

TOPICS
Carrie Marshall
Contributor

Writer, broadcaster, musician and kitchen gadget obsessive Carrie Marshall has been writing about tech since 1998, contributing sage advice and odd opinions to all kinds of magazines and websites as well as writing more than a dozen books. Her memoir, Carrie Kills A Man, is on sale now and her next book, about pop music, is out in 2025. She is the singer in Glaswegian rock band Unquiet Mind.

Latest in CPU
John Loeffler holding the Ryzen 7 7800X3D
Great news! The best gaming CPU ever made is finally available for it's original MSRP again
The Ryzen AI Max+ 395 could power the latest generation of powerful mini PCs
The AMD Ryzen AI Max+ 395 dominates as the "most powerful" APU on the market, but its competition is questionable
Intel Lunar Lake concept
Intel's Panther Lake processors won't arrive until Q1 2026 - corroborates previous delay rumors despite former Intel CEO's promise of 2025 launch
Aoostar G-flip 370
There's no need for a monitor with this Ryzen AI-powered mini PC
The main battle pass characters in Fortnite Lawless, including Midas, Sub Zero and a large wolf-man
You'll finally be able to play Fortnite on Windows 11 Arm-powered laptops as Epic Games partners with Qualcomm
Ryzen 9000 promotional material
AMD's most powerful processor ever actually runs better on Windows 10 than Windows 11
Latest in News
Helly and Mark standing on an artificial hill surrounded by goats in Severance season 2 episode 3
New Apple teaser for Severance season 2 finale suggests we might finally find out what Lumon is doing with those goats, and I don't think it's anything good
Foldable iPhone
Apple’s first foldable iPhone could beat the Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 7 in one key way
Marvel Rivals
Marvel Rivals' next update will add two new hero skins for Iron Man and Spider-Man mains this week
Nvidia Isaac GROOT N1
“The age of generalist robotics is here" - Nvidia's latest GROOT AI model just took us another step closer to fully humanoid robots
Lego Pokemon
Pokemon and Lego announce the most electrifying collaboration of all time and I’m going to be first in line
Apple Watch app health
Apple Watch blood pressure monitoring tech revealed in patent