Netflix’s #3 most-watched TV show ever is returning soon with a new spine-chilling installment in the Monster anthology series

Nicholas Alexander Chavez, Cooper Koch, Chloe Sevigny and Javier Bardem pose as the Menendez family for the second season of Netflix's Monster anthology series
Monster: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story debuts on Netflix on September 19. (Image credit: Netflix)

Every true crime fan’s wish was granted back in 2022 when Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story was dropped on Netflix as it became the platform’s most-watched show at the time – it's currently the best streaming service's third most-watched series ever. Now the anthology’s long-awaited second season has a release date, and this time it follows the story of another case popular among true crime fans. 

Netflix finally dropped the teaser trailer for Monster: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story in March, making it one of the most exciting shows that we couldn't wait for. The second season will be arriving on the platform on September 19 and, as its title implies, will reenact the events around the case of the Menendez brothers who were convicted of murdering their parents in 1989 – one of the most followed true crime stories. 

Being one of the star titles of everything new on Netflix in September 2024, you can expect the second insert in the anthology series to pack an all-star cast. The best Netflix show’s creator Ryan Murphy, aka the king of television anthologies, has roped in a number of his esteemed acting collaborators including Chloë Sevigny, Nathan Lane, and Leslie Grossman, along with Javier Bardem.  

MONSTERS: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story | Official Teaser | Netflix - YouTube MONSTERS: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story | Official Teaser | Netflix - YouTube
Watch On

A mere 54-second trailer (see above) shows the Menendez family sitting for what appears to be an innocent family photo, overlapped by an ominous pulsing sound followed by the motherly plea "I need to know what’s going on between you and the boys". Ending with the brothers embracing each other covered in blood splats, the second season of Murphy’s Monster anthology points to another shocking retelling of a gruesome tale, but this time feels injected with a sense of empathy for the brothers. 

What can you expect from Monster: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story? 

Inspired by the true story of Lyle and Erik Menendez, the second season is set to follow the two brothers (played by Nicholas Alexander Chavez and Cooper Koch) who shot and killed their parents, Kitty and Jose Menendez (Chloë Sevigny & Javier Bardem) in their home in Beverly Hills on August 20, 1989. Following the aftermath of the murder, the brothers were convicted of first-degree murder at ages 21 and 18. 

At the time of the case, the brothers shared that the motive behind their brutal killings stemmed from years of emotional, physical, and sexual abuse from their father, who the brothers believed would kill them if they exposed him. But the prosecutor argued that they committed murder in order to obtain the family’s multi-million dollar estate. 

In the show’s first season, not only did it follow the murders committed by Jeffrey Dahmer between 1978 and 1991 across the 10 episodes, but included scenes that gave an insight to the lives of his victims and the mind of Dahmer himself. Looking at the trailer for the new season, we get the impression that it will follow a similar narrative structure to the first season, but will hit differently on an emotional level. 

You might also like

Rowan Davies
Editorial Associate

Rowan is an Editorial Associate and Apprentice Writer for TechRadar. A recent addition to the news team, he is involved in generating stories for topics that spread across TechRadar's categories. His interests in audio tech and knowledge in entertainment culture help bring the latest updates in tech news to our readers. 

Read more
Dennis Quaid as the Happy Face Killer wearing a red jumpsuit
I can't wait for Paramount Plus' new true crime series after seeing a creepy Dennis Quaid in the trailer for Happy Face
Stephen Graham in the Netflix show Adolescence
The trailer for Netflix’s wild ‘one-take’ mystery thriller Adolescence looks ultra-intense and timely
A figure wearing a skeleton mask stands in front of a sign that reads "Shadyside: High School Senior Prom". The letters DIE in Shadyside are highlighted in red.
I'm saving the date as Fear Street: Prom Queen gets a confirmed Netflix release
The Walking Dead: The Ones Who Live
3 new Netflix shows with over 88% on Rotten Tomatoes that I can't wait to watch this month
Peter looks to the side with the city skyline behind him in The Night Agent season 2
The Night Agent reclaims Netflix’s #1 spot with season 2 – here are 3 of my favorite thrillers with over 90% on Rotten Tomatoes that are just as good
Wednesday crosses her arms in front of an eerie staircase in Wednesday season 2
Wednesday season 2: everything we know about the wildly popular Netflix show's sophomore chapter
Latest in Netflix
Michelle, Keats, and Doctor Amherst looking unimpressed and worried in The Electric State
Netflix drops trailer for The Electric State, and I'm getting serious District 9 vibes
A still from Blade Runner
3 new movies on Netflix in March 2025 with over 90% on Rotten Tomatoes
An image from Welcome to the Family showing to women screaming
Netflix's trailer for a new comedy show that looks like Knives Out meets Weekend at Bernie's – Welcome to the Family seems like chaotic fun
Emily Blunt in Sicario
3 thriller movies coming to Netflix with over 89% on Rotten Tomatoes
A still from Netflix's new miniseries Adolescence starring Stephen Graham
Everything new on Netflix in March 2025 – stream the miniseries Adolescence and new Original movies
Taron Egerton's Ethan puts in an earpiece in Netflix's Carry-On movie
Netflix reveals the most-watched movies and shows of the end of last year, and there are 4 I recommend you catch up on
Latest in News
Google Gemini iPhone Lock Screen
You can now access Gemini from your iPhone's lock screen
Michelle, Keats, and Doctor Amherst looking unimpressed and worried in The Electric State
Netflix drops trailer for The Electric State, and I'm getting serious District 9 vibes
YouTube TV
YouTube TV might be planning a big Netflix update that puts the best streaming services first
Google Pixel 9 Pro
Here are the 7 best Pixel 9 and Pixel Watch 3 features landing in March’s Pixel Feature Drop
Bang & Olufsen Beogram 4000C Saint Laurent Rive Droite Edition
Bang & Olufsen's latest reworked turntable is a masterpiece of retro revival, in a breathtaking wooden presentation box
Apple Watch Series 10
Apple unveils new Apple Watch bands – here's what's in the Spring 2025 collection