Skip to main content

We're shunning smart speakers in favor of voice assistants on our phones

The Amazon Echo (pictured) comes with voice assistant Alexa built-in. (Image credit: Amazon)

Do you have a smart speaker at home? Chances are you're not using it in the way companies like Apple, Amazon, and Google might have hoped. 

A study by Forrester Analytics' Consumer Technographics has found that more of us use smart assistants like Alexa, Siri, and Google Assistant on our smartphones instead of speakers like the Amazon Echo, Google Home, and Apple HomePod.

The study also found that, even if you do use the voice assistant built into your smart speaker, you're probably only asking it to carry out simple tasks.

Having surveyed smart speaker users in the US, Forrester found that "the most common task is checking the weather, at 65% of smart-speaker users, and the least-common, ordering or reordering products, is at 5% of smart-speaker users". 

Small talk

Smart speakers are rarely cheap, and with companies touting them as the potential control hub for all of your smart home devices, many of us aren't using them to their full potential.

One reason for this could be the need to install third-party applets – or in Amazon's case, Alexa Skills – on their voice assistant's smartphone app in order to use features and capabilities specific to that brand.  

Another issue? Perhaps we're collectively so used to looking at a screen that giving voice commands to a virtual assistant still feels a little alien – at least beyond making small talk about the weather. 

Smart displays like the Google Nest Hub Max and the Amazon Echo Show bridge this gap a little, but there's still a disconnect between what our gadgets can do and what we're actually asking of them.

Smart displays like the Google Nest Hub Max (pictured) bring a screen to the smart speaker.

Smart displays like the Google Nest Hub Max (pictured) bring a screen to the smart speaker. (Image credit: Future)

As Frank Gillett, Principal Analyst at Forrester points out, "complex tasks and interactions with brands, such as online searches, checking bills, making payments, or ordering items, are still relatively rare". 

Hopefully, as our voice assistants get smarter through the power of machine learning and artificial intelligence, they'll become more adept at carry out tasks like this. 

Right now, many of us are still understandably too worried about being misheard by our voice assistants in the middle of making an important payment to use online banking (or other sensitive processes) via our smart speakers. 

Whatever the reason for our reluctance to fully trust in our smart speakers, it's clear that the companies behind them could do more to educate us on how we can use them most effectively, beyond cutesy adverts that don't actually explain how to use the mysterious obelisks that sit in our homes, waiting for commands that may never come.