Skip to main content
Tech Radar TechRadar the technology experts
Sign in
  • View Profile
  • Sign out
RSS
Asia
flag of Singapore
Singapore
Europe
flag of Danmark
Danmark
flag of Suomi
Suomi
flag of Norge
Norge
flag of Sverige
Sverige
flag of UK
UK
flag of Italia
Italia
flag of Nederland
Nederland
flag of België (Nederlands)
België (Nederlands)
flag of France
France
flag of Deutschland
Deutschland
flag of España
España
North America
flag of US (English)
US (English)
flag of Canada
Canada
flag of México
México
Australasia
flag of Australia
Australia
flag of New Zealand
New Zealand
  • Phones
  • Computing
  • TVs
  • AI
  • Streaming
  • Health
  • Audio
  • VPN
  • More
    • Cameras
    • Home
    • News
    • Reviews
    • Opinion
    • How to
    • Versus
    • Deals
    • Coupons
    • Best
Tech Radar Pro
Tech Radar Gaming
Trending
  • Memorial Day
  • Computex
  • Google I/O
  • Nintendo Switch 2
  • Best laptop
  • ChatGPT
  • Best VPN
  • NYT Wordle today

Recommended reading

Project Moohan prototype at Samsung Galaxy Unpacked, an XR goggles headset on display in a show area
Virtual Reality & Augmented Reality Samsung's Android XR headset could avoid the Apple Vision Pro's biggest mistake, according to this leak
A ship docked on a red and blue planet, littered with bulbs of glowing light and dense foliage
Virtual Reality Gaming Best VR games 2025 - top virtual reality experiences to play on your headset
Best VR headsets
Virtual Reality Gaming The best VR headsets in 2025: top virtual reality headsets from Meta, Valve and more
The Meta Quest 3 and controllers on their charging station which is itself on a wooden desk next to a lamp
Virtual Reality & Augmented Reality Forget Android XR, I've got my eyes on Vivo's new Meta Quest 3 competitor as it could be the most important VR headset of 2025
Best PS5 controllers DualSense Edge
PS5 Best PS5 controllers in 2025
GameSir Super Nova and GameSir Cyclone 2 side by side, with blue and pink background
Gaming Accessories I’ve tested two of GameSir’s best controllers, and, for me, there’s one clear winner
Virtual Reality & Augmented Reality Does anyone care about VR anymore? It still doesn't have that "killer" app
  1. Gaming
  2. Virtual Reality Gaming

Best VR controller: HTC Vive vs Oculus Rift vs PlayStation VR vs Gear VR

News
By Carrie Marshall published 30 March 2016

We really want to see those fingers…

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

Introduction

Introduction

Virtual Reality (VR) is the most hyped technology of 2016, and in the coming months we'll see early adopters spending huge amounts of money on huge glasses to strap to their heads.

But there's more to VR than what you see. There's how you move around, how you interact with objects and how you go pew-pew-pew when you're playing a VR shooter.

Each of the big consumer VR players has a slightly different approach to controllers, and those differences can make for surprisingly different VR experiences. Let's discover what the options are and explore all this in more depth.

  • Also check out: The best VR headsets 2016
Page 1 of 6
Page 1 of 6
HTC Vive

HTC Vive

The Vive's wireless controllers remind us of slightly less gaudy PlayStation Move sticks, and they're essentially redesigned Steam Machine controllers made for stand-up rather than sit-down play.

The controllers are motion-tracked and include a trackpad with haptic feedback, a two-stage finger trigger, squeeze buttons and a home button. They're wireless and should last for around four hours on a single charge, and they can be tracked around a 15 x 15-foot room. That's three times larger than the space tracked by Oculus VR.

The Vive's controllers are very accurate and definitely make the VR experience more realistic, but some early testers found them a little uncomfortable for smaller hands and the need to hold them like handles might not be ideal for sufferers of RSI.

The Vive controllers have one big advantage over some rivals – they're bundled with every system. That means developers can be 100% confident that they're the controllers people have sitting around, and they can design their apps accordingly. That isn't the case for other VR platforms, some of which don't have dedicated controllers at all.

Page 2 of 6
Page 2 of 6
Oculus Rift

Oculus Rift

Oculus calls its controllers Oculus Touch, and they look rather like somebody sawed a DualShock controller in half and stuck handles on each bit. Each controller has action buttons, a thumbstick and an analogue trigger, a grip button and motion tracking, and early testers report that they're both comfortable and accurate, feeling more like a traditional gamepad than other options.

The controllers can be tracked around a 5 x 5-foot space, enabling you to control VR by ducking and diving as well as waving your hands around.

There's a big problem, though, and that's timing: the Touch controllers won't be ready when the Oculus Rift ships, and that means they're optional – like the Kinect became with the Xbox One. Remember how every Xbox owner rushed out to get one? Exactly. That's a worry for developers, because it means that they can't be certain any given user will have Touch controllers, and it's a worry for consumers if developers don't see Oculus Touch as a key part of the system.

There are signs of that happening already – while the rival Vive system can also be played with a standard game controller, most of the VR demos we've seen for the platform so far have used the magic wands. On Oculus, more demos have used the Xbox One controller.

Page 3 of 6
Page 3 of 6
PlayStation VR

PlayStation VR

Sony's VR controller has been hiding in plain sight for years – it's the Move, which launched in 2009. Sony hasn't been time travelling; it developed the Move with VR in mind, even though it didn't have a VR product. That's good, because lots of us are already familiar with Move, but it's bad because Move lacks the flexibility and VR-ness of dedicated VR controllers such as Oculus Touch.

Where those controllers feel like extensions of your hands, Move feels like it always did – like you're waving a couple of remote controls around. You could always use a DualShock 4 instead, but while that's a great gaming controller it doesn't deliver the same immersion as two separate hand controllers. Surprisingly enough, it feels like playing any other PlayStation game.

It's becoming apparent that Sony is approaching VR from the opposite direction to HTC and Oculus. Their systems are designed solely for VR, but Sony's taking an existing system – the PS4 – and adding VR to it. That's not necessarily a bad thing, but Sony admits that its focus on making an affordable mass market product means that rivals may well deliver a better overall VR experience.

Page 4 of 6
Page 4 of 6
Gear VR

Gear VR

The Gear VR doesn't actually have its own controllers – users are simply connecting third-party gamepads to control their virtual apps – but Samsung's working on this: its Rink controllers were demoed at CES 2016 in January and supplemented with a video that raised more questions than it answered.

The Rink controllers look like big plastic knuckle dusters and seem to rely on an additional head-mounted sensor, presumably there to track their motion, and the demo suggested that the Gear VR will be able to mimic individual fingers rather than just whole hands – so for example you might type on a virtual keyboard.

It's unclear whether Rink achieves that through individual sensors on the controllers or through watching your hands via the additional sensor, but it's a clever idea – wiggling your fingers is a lot more intuitive than trying to remember which button you're supposed to press.

It's all very exciting, but it does seem rather far off too; the video shows that the system is clearly still very laggy, fairly imprecise and quite crash-prone. So far Rink feels more like a preview of Samsung's thinking than a product that's close to shipping any time soon – and that's underlined by the fact it's coming from Samsung's Creative Lab, aka C-Lab, which creates experimental devices that may not make it into production.

Page 5 of 6
Page 5 of 6
The ones that didn't make it

The ones that didn't make it

In this feature we've concentrated on the big four of consumer VR, but of course there are plenty of other systems available or in development for virtual/augmented reality.

Meta Glasses and Microsoft Hololens (pictured) overlay virtual imagery on the real world. Fove's headset will use eye tracking to enable the system to "see" what you're focusing on. Leap Motion offers gesture control for VR and desktop apps alike, while Sulon Q manages to cram a Windows 10 PC with voice and gesture support into a VR headset. And finally, Google Cardboard turns Android phones into headsets via the magic of paper.

The VR market's getting awfully crowded already, often with incompatible systems, and that's something OSVR hopes to address – for gamers, anyway. With backers including Razer, Leap Motion, Intel and Gearbox Software, OSVR hopes to forge a common standard for VR gaming to avoid fragmentation, incompatibility and consumer confusion.

Page 6 of 6
Page 6 of 6
TOPICS
Sony Samsung
Carrie Marshall
Carrie Marshall
Social Links Navigation

Contributor

Writer, broadcaster, musician and kitchen gadget obsessive Carrie Marshall has been writing about tech since 1998, contributing sage advice and odd opinions to all kinds of magazines and websites as well as writing more than twenty books. Her latest, a love letter to music titled Small Town Joy, is on sale now. She is the singer in spectacularly obscure Glaswegian rock band Unquiet Mind.

Read more
Project Moohan prototype at Samsung Galaxy Unpacked, an XR goggles headset on display in a show area
Samsung's Android XR headset could avoid the Apple Vision Pro's biggest mistake, according to this leak
A ship docked on a red and blue planet, littered with bulbs of glowing light and dense foliage
Best VR games 2025 - top virtual reality experiences to play on your headset
Best VR headsets
The best VR headsets in 2025: top virtual reality headsets from Meta, Valve and more
The Meta Quest 3 and controllers on their charging station which is itself on a wooden desk next to a lamp
Forget Android XR, I've got my eyes on Vivo's new Meta Quest 3 competitor as it could be the most important VR headset of 2025
Best PS5 controllers DualSense Edge
Best PS5 controllers in 2025
GameSir Super Nova and GameSir Cyclone 2 side by side, with blue and pink background
I’ve tested two of GameSir’s best controllers, and, for me, there’s one clear winner
Latest in Virtual Reality Gaming
Agent 47 wearing the PSVR 2 headset
With games like Hitman World of Assassination, the PSVR 2 might finally convince me it's better than my Meta Quest 3 after all
An MTA train parked at a station
This beginner-friendly train-driving simulator is the chillest Meta Quest 3 game I've played – but it's not for everyone
Hitman's Agent 47 strangling someone while dressed as a sailor
‘Never say never’ – we ask Hitman developer if Project 007 is coming to VR, and learn how Hitman VR was fixed for PSVR 2
Agent 47 holding up duel pistols with a PSVR 2 headset outline over his head
I can’t believe it either, Hitman on PSVR 2 is actually, finally a great VR port of the World of Assassination trilogy – and my new favorite way to play the series
Meta Quest 3 in white with Batman: Arkham Shadow bundle on red background with don't miss text
Get a $50 gift card with this Meta Quest 3 + Batman Arkham Shadow bundle at Best Buy
Latest in News
Dell Technologies World 2025
“The Windows 10 end of life is coming, and we are ready” - Dell CEO on why your next laptop will probably be an AI PC
Dell technologies world 2025
"The real danger is staying still” - Dell CEO Michael Dell claims AI is "the new electricity"
Netflix and Sesame Street
Netflix is picking up Sesame Street and doing something HBO should've done all along
A toy Amazon Echo next to the Alexa Plus logo and a range of Echo devices
The curious case of the missing Alexa+ users – many are still waiting for 'early access'
Qualcomm and Computex
Qualcomm isn’t giving us new Snapdragon chips at Computex - but there’s a surprise waiting in September
Apple Intelligence on an iPhone and iPad.
Apple-Alibaba deal raises concerns over data access with US lawmakers
LATEST ARTICLES
  1. 1
    MSI's new Nintendo Switch 2 rival is official – here are 3 reasons why I'm excited about the AMD-powered Claw A8
  2. 2
    I tried the trend of using ChatGPT to turn photos into Renaissance paintings: here’s how to do it
  3. 3
    “The Windows 10 end of life is coming, and we are ready” - Dell CEO on why your next laptop will probably be an AI PC
  4. 4
    "What on earth?" Doctor Who fans react to confusing teaser image after Mrs Flood's identity was finally revealed
  5. 5
    Get $80 off the Samsung Galaxy Watch 7 and a free strap in the Memorial Day sales

TechRadar is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site.

  • About Us
  • Contact Future's experts
  • Contact Us
  • Terms and conditions
  • Privacy policy
  • Cookies policy
  • Advertise with us
  • Web notifications
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Careers

© Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.

Please login or signup to comment

Please wait...