Skip to main content

Apple wants Android source code in Samsung patent case

Apple wants Google Android open source code
Apple wants all of Android's jelly beans

Apple is looking to force Google to turn over its Android source code as part of the company's ongoing patent lawsuit with Samsung.

Before a U.S. magistrate judge this week, Apple accused Google of improperly withholding pretrial information related to the mobile operating system, according to Bloomberg.

Specifically, the company is seeking all of the search terms that Google is using to discover documents that Apple has requested.

"It's a question of transparency," Mark Lyon, a lawyer for Apple, to a U.S. magistrate. "We have concerns that they're not doing a full search."

Google's defense

Google is caught up in the Apple vs Samsung lawsuit because it "provides much of the accused functionality," said the lawyer for Apple in a case filing.

True enough, Google's Android mobile operating system runs the Samsung smartphones that have been at the heart of the trial, including the Epic 4G and Galaxy S2.

But Matthew Warren, an attorney for the Mountain View company who is also representing Samsung, didn't see the fairness behind Apple's petition.

Google, he argued before the judge, doesn't have the same legal rights, like "reciprocal discovery," as a third-party to the case.

The search terms are "future discovery that we don't think [Apple is] entitled to," and could lead to "ideas about how to proceed that they wouldn't have had."

Second lawsuit just heating up

The judge has not declared whether or not Google will have to provide Apple with all of the Android information being sought in this second patent lawsuit between Apple and Samsung.

Samsung was found guilty of the first patent infringement case last year after a jury found that Samsung was violating six of Apple's patents.

That jury awarded Apple $1.049 billion (£675 million, AU$1.03 billion) in August, but a judge halved that amount due to jury errors three months later and ordered the new trial, which ensures more back-and-forth legal squabbling between all of the companies.

Matt Swider

US Editor-in-Chief

Matt Swider is TechRadar's gadget-savvy, globe-trotting US Editor-in-Chief Editor who leads the US team in New York City. He began his tech journalism career all the way back in 1999 at the ripe at of 14, and first started writing for TechRadar in 2012. He's tested over 1,000 phones, tablets and wearables and commands a Twitter account of 600,000+ followers. Matt received his journalism degree from Penn State University and is never seen without his TechRadar headphones.