Are custom liquid-cooled PCs even worth it anymore? Why we’re fast approaching the end for bespoke cooling

A Phanteks water block on a graphics card, with a large red cross over it.
(Image credit: Phanteks)

I’ve been building PCs as a hobby since the early 2000s, and have been lucky enough to forge a career around it for the last ten years as well. It’s a critical part of my life, and without it, I wouldn’t even have the opportunity to sit here and write for TechRadar today.

It’s radical, really: I remember sitting down and watching copious amounts of Jayztwocents content on liquid cooling back in 2013/2014, and I lusted after those builds. After all, liquid-cooled machines are just incredible things to behold. Since then I’ve built numerous liquid-cooled systems, for both personal use and for publication too.

Getting into the industry in 2015, the first thing on my mind was building my own custom liquid-cooled rig. The time was right: SLI, Crossfire, hot chips that responded well to larger cooling solutions, big massive cases with a huge amount of radiator support, and awesome liquid-cooled water blocks and particle coolant dominated the market. AIOs were commonplace, sure, but the largest ones landed at 280mm at most, and none of them provided the true guts and glory that a custom rig could get you. I even built a few of them here at TechRadar.

A custom desktop gaming PC with a liquid cooling loop.

This PC was built back in 2017, the liquid-cooling heyday, with SLI Titan cards and liquid-cooled X-series CPUs . (Image credit: Future)

Today though, that landscape has changed massively. It’s changed in ways that back then we just couldn’t predict, and with EKWB and other cooling manufacturers struggling to make a dent in the market or falling foul of financial issues, among other concerns, it got me thinking about whether this might just be the end for that age-old passion of ours. Liquid cooling might just be on its way out - at least, for the time being. 

 Then vs Now: what’s changed?

For those not in the know, liquid cooling for personal PCs and rigs first came about in the late 90s and early 2000s, as a remedy to the overclocking attempts of the day. CPU cooling was in its infancy, and the chips themselves were easily unlocked. Apply a little voltage and a higher multiplier and you could quite quickly boost performance significantly, as long as you could manage the heat. Plumbing parts were often used as substitutes in those early days.

Over time, companies emerged from that premise. EKWB, Alphacool, and Primochill to name just a few, and with them products were developed, and that was then expanded well into the mid-2010s. Because AMD didn’t provide much in the way of competition back then, it meant that Intel’s 3rd, 4th, 6th, and 7th gen Core processors were typically quite undervolted as standard, and underclocked as a result, with the company leaning more on efficiency and temperatures rather than brute performance. The architectures were effectively under-utilized, and with sufficient cooling and some tweaks in the BIOS it was quite easy to get some significant performance boosts with the help of fully liquid-cooled systems.

AMD Ryzen

AMD's Ryzen chips revitalized the CPU race and forever changed the PC-building landscape. (Image credit: AMD)

Then Ryzen arrived, and all of a sudden the battle was on between Intel and AMD again, with each company reacting to the other, rapidly developing generations of processors, with smaller transistors, more cores, and higher clock speeds. That led to hotter chips as a result. We moved away from IHSs with thermal paste, to fully soldered articles and voltages ramped up too. Soon enough, turbo-boosts and smart auto-overclocking elements were baked in as standard across both sides of the aisle, almost eliminating the overclocking hobby for most amateurs in the process. With little headroom left in each architecture and the chips and BIOS effectively auto-volting and overclocking parts, it became almost pointless to try and eke out any extra edge manually.

Similarly, case manufacturers and cooling companies followed suit, producing chassis and coolers that could help alleviate that extra temperature for the masses. 360mm and 420mm AIOs became the norm, and are still the go-to best coolers for those looking to build a PC today, even in the smallest of ITX cases.

On the flip side, the GPU race splintered off as well, AMD lost the flagship performance fight, and as GPUs became more specialized, utilizing ray tracing and AI componentry, the cooling solutions included became even more gargantuan in the process. Find me a top-tier GPU today that, under load, runs hotter than 85 C. It’s almost impossible. I’ve got two RTX 4080s here, one an FE Super, the other a Gigabyte Aero OC. Both are practically the size of concrete blocks - and both never ramp up to more than 73 C, even under the most intense of loads.

 So what’s the point? 

Here’s the thing: back in the day, you could argue for liquid cooling in one of two ways. It was cooler for sure, and it was quieter too than a standard AIO build.

Today though, those arguments are pretty moot. Both Intel and AMD chips at stock run at ridiculously high temperatures already, even with a 420mm AIO or custom loop on them, and now we’ve got plenty of master-crafted fans and controllers around to mitigate that noise build-up too, with BIOS software being far more forgiving at fixed speeds.

Then there’s the convenience. The reality is that, although custom liquid-cooled builds require no small amount of skill and look incredible, they’re massively awkward in comparison to a closed AIO loop. Say you want to swap out a CPU, or a graphics card? If it’s a hard loop, you have to drain the entire system and disassemble it. If it’s soft-tubing, and doesn’t have quick-disconnects, then you might be able to get away with just loosening components, but the chance of a leak is considerably increased. Then you have to swap out the coolant, deal with rubber sealants failing, the works. It’s incredibly difficult to justify, unless you’re not going to be doing anything to your system long-term - but that includes troubleshooting or swapping out failed parts, which can happen to the best of us.

A custom desktop gaming PC with a liquid cooling loop featuring bright purple coolant..

It’s been five years, I still haven’t stripped down this PC properly…  (Image credit: Future)

From a cooling perspective as well, there are diminishing returns thanks to some fairly hefty bottlenecks too. That CPU has a limited surface area for it to transfer heat away from the IHS and into the CPU block, and most modern 360mm AIOs will be more than enough to deal with that extra heat.

Subjectively, with some of the best modern AIOs featuring all manner of LCD screens, and GPU heatsinks now looking equally as incredible, the buzz around a beautifully crafted liquid-cooled build just isn't there anymore. Perhaps that’s the reason why companies like EKWB are struggling. No matter how you look at it, unless the market dramatically changes and managing heat becomes more of a critical issue, and we’re given more headroom in these CPUs, there’s just very little reason to go down the fully custom liquid-cooled route. Sit any hardcore long-term PC-builder down and ask them if their next rig is going to be liquid-cooled or not, I think you’ll be surprised at the answer you get.

Zak Storey
Freelance contributor

Zak is one of TechRadar's multi-faceted freelance tech journalists. He's written for an absolute plethora of tech publications over the years and has worked for Techradar on and off since 2015. Most famously, Zak led Maximum PC as its Editor-in-Chief from 2020 through to the end of 2021, having worked his way up from Staff Writer. Zak currently writes for Maximum PC, TechRadar, PCGamesN, and Trusted Reviews. He also had a stint working as Corsair's Public Relations Specialist in the UK, which has given him a particularly good insight into the inner workings of larger companies in the industry. He left in 2023, coming back to journalism once more. When he's not building PCs, reviewing hardware, or gaming, you can often find Zak working at his local coffee shop as First Barista, or out in the Wye Valley shooting American Flat Bows.

Read more
Person using a screwdriver to install a part in a PC case
Built vs Bought: why prebuilt systems are always superior to custom gaming PCs
An unhappy PC Gamer sat at their desk
Building a gaming PC is too expensive, and GPUs really aren't helping
A person standing in front of a rack of servers inside a data center
Direct-to-chip, single-phase and dual-phase cooling explained
A stock photo of a man saying 'no thank you' to a gift box bearing the AMD Ryzen logo.
I'm tired of waiting for AMD's entry-level Ryzen 9000 series chips
Racks of servers inside a data center.
Cooling high-density data centers with coolant distribution units
A picture of the grando comino workstation without the lid, exposing eight GPUs
Want a PC with 8 (yes, 8) AMD Radeon RX 7900 XTX GPUs? Here’s one and OMG, you could even add Intel Arc GPUs
Latest in Computing Components
An Nvidia GeForce RTX 4060 Ti
Nvidia could unleash RTX 5060 and 5060 Ti GPUs on PC gamers tomorrow, but there’s no sign of rumored RTX 5050 yet
MSI's four available motherboard sizes
Motherboard sizes explained: which should you buy in 2025?
An Nvidia GeForce RTX 4060 on a table with its retail packaging
Nvidia RTX 5060 GPU spotted in Acer gaming PC, suggesting rumors of imminent launch are correct – and that it’ll run with only 8GB of video RAM
An AMD Radeon RX 9070 XT made by Sapphire on a table with its retail packaging
Want to buy an RX 9070 or 9070 XT but fed up of the GPUs being out of stock? AMD promises that “more supply is coming ASAP”
AMD RX 9070 GPU models
Modders do what AMD can't (or won't) by adding FSR 4 support to more games
An AMD Ryzen 9 9950X3D on its retail packaging
I've reviewed three generations of 3D V-cache processors, and the AMD Ryzen 9 9950X3D is the best there is
Latest in Features
Gemini on a smartphone.
I used Gemini AI to declutter my Gmail inbox and saved myself 5 hours a week – here’s how you can do the same
A representational concept of a social media network
What are data removal services?
Man adjusting settings on Garmin Fenix 6 watch
5 hidden features on your Garmin watch you're probably not using, but should be
Susan holding her baby in Toxic Town.
Netflix's #3 show has a flawless 100% on Rotten Tomatoes – here are 3 more powerful dramas to watch after Toxic Town
Devil May Cry's Dante has his back to the camera, holding onto a large sword
Netflix's official Devil May Cry trailer features music from my favorite alternative rock band and it's taken me on a serious nostalgia trip
MSI's four available motherboard sizes
Motherboard sizes explained: which should you buy in 2025?