Xbox One S All-Digital Edition review

Are discs a dealbreaker?

Xbox One S All-Digital Edition Review

Our Verdict

The Xbox One S All-Digital looks and performs like its predecessor – minus the disc drive. It's more convenient for those who are happy to do away with physical discs, offering plenty of space for digital downloads, but struggles to live up to its price tag.

For

  • 1TB hard drive
  • Three games included
  • More convenient
  • 4K & HDR streaming

Against

  • Price tag isn't justifiable
  • Not for those who prefer discs
  • Looks the same as the Xbox One S

As digital downloads and online streaming have changed how we consume film, TV, entertainment and games, it's no huge surprise that Microsoft has launched its first disc-less console. 

The Xbox One S All-Digital Edition is essentially the same console as the Xbox One S in design, performance and game availability. The one key difference? It doesn't have a disc-drive and therefore can't play physical discs. 

The All-Digital isn't aiming to compete with the more powerful Xbox One X, instead aiming to offer a more streamlined gaming console. 

If you're someone who enjoys having a physical library of games to swoon over, then immediately the All-Digital probably isn't for you. But if you're ready to ditch the disc and live a more minimalist and, arguably, more convenient gaming life then there are some pros and cons to weigh up before investing in Microsoft's digital console.

Xbox One S All-Digital Edition: price and release date

  • What is it? Microsoft's disc-less version of the Xbox One S
  • When did it come out? May 2019
  • What does it cost? $249 / £199 / AU$349 

Xbox One S All-Digital Edition: design

Xbox One S All-Digital Edition Review

(Image credit: TechRadar)
  • No disc drive
  • Same visual design as Xbox One S 
  • Only comes in white

The Xbox One S All-Digital Edition's design is the exact same as that of the Xbox One S - except it doesn't have a disc-drive. 

The sleek console is conveniently compact, measuring just 11.6 x 8.9 x 2.5 inches (L x W x D) despite its 1TB hard drive and lack of power supply pack. That makes it just a few inches smaller than the Xbox One S.

There is one physical button for power on the face of the console as well as a USB 3.0.  Around the back, you'll find an HDMI In port that allows you to pass in a cable box, an HDMI Out, two USB 3.0s, and S/PDIF and Ethernet ports. There's an IR blaster on the front of the console that allows you to turn on other devices, like your TV, audio/video receiver, and cable/satellite box.

However if you like your consoles in loud color schemes – or anything other than white – you're out of luck. Like the Xbox One S, Microsoft's Xbox Design Lab program only allows you to to customize the color of your controllers, so when it comes to the console itself you're limited to white.

Xbox One S All-Digital Edition: performance

Xbox One S All-Digital Edition Review

(Image credit: TechRadar)
  • 1TB hard drive
  • 4K & HDR streaming
  • Cloud storage
  • Spatial Audio

Again like the Xbox One S, the All-Digital boasts 4K resolution - but that's upscaled 4K, not native 4K like the Xbox One X. You'll notice a few more details with the latter, but the former still proves pretty capable here.

For example, while playing Forza Horizon 3, we had no issue with dropped frames interrupting our experience, but there's no doubt the game looks better - and runs smoother - on the X. 

So far, NetflixAmazon Video, YouTube and US-exclusives Vudu and Hulu all have 4K versions of their apps available on the Xbox One Store, which should cover most of your streaming needs - and you'll need it without the built-in Blu-ray player. 

We had no issue with the All-Digital when it came to streaming shows, downloading games/apps or general functionality. The console doesn't take up much room and doesn't sound like an air plane taking off when its running, while the 1TB hard drive allows you to download plenty of games (but we'll get to that a bit later).

Xbox One S All-Digital Edition: game library

Xbox One S All-Digital Edition Review

(Image credit: TechRadar)
  • Digital game library
  • Can play same titles as Xbox One S
  • Comes with three digital game codes

Here's where the Xbox One S All-Digital Edition will divide players. As the console doesn't have a disc-drive, you can't use physical games with it – at all. 

So what are your options? For a start, the console comes with three digital codes: Forza Horizon 3, Sea of Thieves and Minecraft. While getting three games straight off the bat is great, arguably Microsoft could have included some newer titles - maybe Forza Horizon 4 instead of 3, for example. Still, Minecraft and Sea of Thieves are still quite popular and all games are family friendly. 

Outside of these three games, you can either buy digital versions of Xbox games from the Microsoft Store or take advantage of Xbox Game Pass. We found the Xbox One S All-Digital to be a great companion for Game Pass, with plenty of room to download titles at your will from the services library of over 200 games - including old and new.

Even better, for the last month, Microsoft has been running a deal which gives you one month of the new Xbox Game Pass Ultimate service for $1 / £1 instead of the standard $14.99 / £10.99.

Final verdict

Xbox One S All-Digital Edition Review

(Image credit: TechRadar)

When the Xbox One S arrived three years on from the original Xbox One, it offered smaller, quieter, higher-quality gaming machine. It soon became the de facto Xbox system. But since then we've seen the release of the powerhouse Xbox One X console, which offers 4K HDR gaming and the most premium gaming experience on a console (until the release of Xbox Project Scarlett next year).

The release of the Xbox One X raised the bar for gaming consoles and while it didn't make the Xbox One S necessarily redundant, it certainly highlighted the aged system of the Xbox One S.

That's why it's surprising that Microsoft has chosen to release a disc-less version of the S, which is essentially the same console but without a disc drive. The look is the same, the performance is the same and there's nothing that particularly makes it stand out from the pack. The draw of the original S is that it provides a cheaper Xbox alternative to the X and works for those who don't necessary have a 4K compatible screen. However, the All-Digital takes the same console and makes it a tad simpler.

For those who love the idea of disc-less gaming then the All-Digital may be prove appealing, but the issue we had was with the price. While Microsoft is claiming the All-Digital ($249 / £199) is cheaper than the Xbox One S ($299 MSRP / £249 RRP), in reality you can pick up an Xbox One S bundle for around the same price from certain retailers. 

For example, at the time of writing, over on our Xbox One deals (UK) page you could pick up a purple 1TB Xbox One S bundled with Fortnite DLC, Tekken 7 and Project Cars 2 for just £209 at Currys. And it's not a rare sight to see the console on its own go for around £190. Over on the Xbox One deals (USA) guide you'll find highlights from just $199 including either Minecraft or Battlefield V.