A US federal judge has found merit in a lawsuit alleging that Apple sold defective MacBook Pro (opens in new tab) laptops despite being aware of the quality issues.
Referred to in some circles as flexgate, the issue centers on MacBook Pro machines sold since 2016 that have notoriously flimsy flex display (opens in new tab) cables that apparently begin to wear out after a short period of use. This results in weird display anomalies, most notably the "stage light" effect, when too much backlight bleeds through the bottom bezel of the panel.
In the lawsuit, the complainants allege that Apple’s extensive pre-release testing, which would have included stress tests, must surely have brought the issue with the cables to the company's attention.
- Here are some of the best business Macs (opens in new tab)
- These are the best business computers (opens in new tab) currently available
- And, here's our list of the best business laptops (opens in new tab)
“The court finds that the allegations of pre-release testing in combination with the allegations of substantial customer complaints are sufficient to show that Apple had exclusive knowledge of the alleged defect,” wrote Judge Edward Davila in his order.
In the know
Apple’s response to the issue when it first came to light didn’t help matters either. The complainants assert that not only did Apple silently replace the cables (opens in new tab) in newer MacBooks, but also that the firm deleted forum posts about the issue.
The company is also said to have refused to replace the defective components, until thousands of users signed an online petition.
Notably, flexgate has already led to one class action lawsuit based around the MacBook keyboard (opens in new tab).
However, according to Law360 (opens in new tab), although Judge Davila has allowed the flex cable lawsuit to proceed, he has narrowed its scope. A class-action lawsuit has not yet been certified, but the judge has invited the nine plaintiffs to submit a new amended complaint.
- Need something more portable? Check out the best mobile workstations (opens in new tab)