Hands on: Nintendo Switch review

Switching up the gaming landscape once more

What is a hands on review?
TODO alt text

Our Early Verdict

Innovative and fun, the Switch looks set to make Nintendo cool again.

For

  • Unique design
  • Interesting announced titles
  • Great tablet screen

Against

  • Battery concerns
  • Online offering
  • Few confirmed launch day titles

The Nintendo Switch is quite unlike anything that's come before it. With one part console, one part handheld, and a little bit of tablet and motion-control gaming in there for good measure, the new device feels like an attempt by Nintendo to bring together all the various strands of gaming into one cohesive whole. 

Now, after having had the chance to try out the console in the comfort of our own homes, our view on it has developed significantly since the brief time we we had to play with it at Nintendo's event back in January. 

What seems initially clear is that the Nintendo Switch gets a lot of things right that the Wii U stumbled on. For one, the device feels like a premium piece of kit rather than a children's toy, and when it comes to online Nintendo seems to be on the right track with a unified account system that finally links all your games together. 

It's still not the perfect machine. In an attempt to make a hybrid Nintendo has created a console that neither has the graphical horsepower of a home console, nor the battery life of a true portable. 

But being at the cutting edge has never been Nintendo's aim. Instead its desire is creating innovative games and experiences that often have a level of polish few others can dream of. So far the Nintendo Switch seems to have the right ideas about how to push the envelope, but read on for our full thoughts. 

Design

With the Nintendo Switch, the home of Mario has done away with the concept of one fixed box sat under your telly. Instead, it exists in two distinct states: firstly as a portable tablet device with a built-in kickstand, and secondly docked in a base that connects to your TV. 

Paired with its breakaway, adaptable controllers it’s a bit like Nintendo’s answer to the Transformers, ready to be reconfigured depending on your current gaming need. Sat at home ready for a marathon session? Plug the tablet into the dock and beam your gameplay onto the big screen.

Sat on a train with a table in front of you and the Switch in your bag? Pop out the tablet unit’s kickstand, grab the nunchuck-like controller parts and get playing. Roaming a park? Plug the two controller sticks in either side of the screen and you can walk about and collect those Zelda rupees at the same time.

The Switch feels like a premium piece of kit rather than the childlike plastic construction of the Wii U. It’s not exactly ditching its family-friendly ambitions (after all, one of the console versions comes with bright blue and red controllers, and motion controls are still a big focus) but it knows it has to win over the older, so-called 'hardcore' gamer reared on a diet of sci-fi shooters.

There are two pieces of hardware that create this hybrid experience. You've got a dock that sits underneath your TV with an HDMI out connector and a USB Type-C port to both charge your console and to transmit its video feed to the TV. There are also a couple of USB ports on the side and rear for charging additional controllers, much like a traditional console. 

The dock is simple, if slightly light and cheap-feeling. Its rubber feet means it does a good job at staying in place despite its light weight, and its matte black design looks pleasing enough when placed in front of our TV at home. 

The real magic happens with the handheld portion of the device. The central screen is capable of producing bright, vibrant, images, and we think it's possibly the best gaming handheld screen we've ever seen – if you don't include top-end smartphones, that is.

Its two controllers detach easily using small buttons on the rear, and it's a simple process to press this button to unlock them before sliding them out for portable play.  

One thing that's immediately apparent when you get the console out of the box is just how many accessories there are with this console, and we'd be amazed if most people didn't lose one or two over time. 

As well as the two Joy-Cons (one for each hand), you've got a couple of straps which give them both shoulder-buttons and a Joy-Con grip to turn them into a single controller (although the one provided with the console won't charge them). 

Considering you're going to have to dismantle the Joy-Con every time you want to charge the controllers (which you'll need to do by plugging them back into the main Switch unit), there's a high likelihood of many of these bits going missing over time. 

Specs and performance

But how does that experience stack up against the competition? Has Nintendo managed, for the first time in decades, to get its hardware on a level footing with the PS4 and Xbox One competition? Though you can argue that the unique form factor negates such comparisons, the simple answer is “not quite”.

The Nintendo Switch is a solidly capable machine, but its internals appear far more power-efficiency focussed than geared towards pure processing grunt; certainly, at its first press event, there appear to be no games challenging the visual fidelity of Sony or Microsoft's consoles. 

Although that's never really been the point of a Nintendo console with the company far more concerned with innovative gameplay forms than photo-real visuals, it's still disappointing to see Zelda: Breath of the Wild dropping frames in its more open and graphically intensive areas. 

This is especially disappointing considering this game in particular was originally developed with the last-generation Wii U in mind. 

Under the hood of its core tablet unit you’ll find a custom Nvidia Tegra processor, broadly comparable to the Tegra X1 found in an Nvidia Shield TV. 32GB of storage space is onboard too (some of which is dedicated to the system software), along with 802.11ac Wi-Fi.

The screen itself is, of course, a critical part of the equation – especially given how disappointing the Wii U’s comparable Gamepad proved to be. The Switch screen measures out at 6.2 inches, with a resolution of 720p. 

It proves itself to be a very enjoyable screen to view. It has vibrant colors, a relatively sharp resolution, and is able to keep up with the breakneck nature of Mario Kart 8 Deluxe, which we had hands-on time with. It's not as impressive as the best phone screens, but it feels dramatically better than what the Wii U Gamepad offered.

The touchscreen is responsive enough, but it's nowhere near the level of a dedicated smartphone. So far it's worked well to simplify the often-nightmarish process of trying to type on an on-screen keyboard using a controller, but outside of menu situations like this we can't see developers relying on it too much. 

Supporting Wi-Fi online play, up to eight Nintendo Switch consoles can link up for local multiplayer play, and when we used this to play Mario Kart at an event there wasn't any evidence of lag.

Battery life for on-the-go play is, of course, a concern. Nintendo quotes a very heartening six-plus hours of battery life when the Switch is disconnected from a USB-C power supply, although that's very much dependant on the title being played – Nintendo admits, for instance, that you'll get closer to three hours play when firing up The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild when out and about.

We'll have to take the Switch out into the real world to see if that claimed upper range holds up.

Docked vs portable play

So, how do the two core gaming experiences (untethered on-the-go versus docked-at-home play) compare? So far, very favourably.

The Switch outputs to a TV at a resolution of 1080p, with 5.1 audio output offered. Considering the home console standard really remains at 1080p (with the exception of the adaptive-up-to-4K resolution of the PS4 Pro), that’s competitive. Charging from the dock, it doesn’t of course come with any battery power limitations.

On a 1080p television there were more jagged edges visible on the console, but frame-rate so far doesn't seem to be impacted by form factor. 

The docking and undocking process is as seamless as can be. We got a chance to try out Breath of the Wild in both configurations, and even switching mid-gameplay presented no trouble to the console – you just hold a couple of buttons to confirm you're using the attached Joy-Con controllers, and the game resumes exactly where you left off.

The seamlessness of this process is thanks to the fact that the USB connector inside the dock is actually recessed. When you place the tablet into the dock it pushes a couple of buttons which cause the USB Type-C port to be pushed into the console. 

It's a neat trick that means that we've never had any trouble getting the console to dock. 

Online, interface and apps

Compared to the slick, richly web-connected interfaces of the PS4 and Xbox One, Nintendo’s most recent console interfaces have felt more than a little dated. The Switch attempts to shake this up by introducing its own online subscription service, but those looking for something comparable to PlayStation Plus or Xbox Live Gold may be left wanting.

Though Nintendo still needs to clarify some points, its subscription service's 'free' monthly game offering seems quite stingy. It appears that you'll only get access to one NES or SNES game (with Super Nintendo titles now offering online support) each month, with just one month in which to play them. The Xbox Live Gold alternative, for instance, offers multiple modern games for subscribers to download and keep each month, forever

In addition, the online service offers lobby and voice chat, but again this appears clunkily limited to a phone app. With the likes of WhatsApp and Facebook Messenger already letting you hook up with friends for free on your phone, this hardly seems a reasonable alternative to a built-in console chat option.

Nintendo subscribers will also get digital store discounts, but that doesn't seem like much of a draw in itself. The Switch will launch with a free trial to its subscription service – we'll keep you informed as to whether it's worth sticking with beyond that, when the paid service launches in Autumn 2017.

Unfortunately the console will include neither support for video streaming apps, nor feature a web browser of its own, two features that have been included on both of its main competitors. 

If you're looking for your Switch to be your all-in-one media machine then you're going to be disappointed. This is a device that's all about the games rather than a multimedia hub. 

Controller

Nintendo has a habit of designing quirky controllers, from the motion-sensing Wii remotes and nunchucks to the trident-shaped N64 pad, with each bringing with it a new way to play. While the Switch’s Joy-Con controllers don't offer any remarkable new input options, they are innovative in the way they can transform depending on your current needs.

It’s a bit like the Wii remote / nunchuck pairing in use – you have a left-hand element that includes an analogue stick and direction buttons (sacrilegiously moving away from Nintendo’s iconic 'cross' design” in favor of separate buttons) alongside a 'minus' options button, a Capture button for recording gameplay and a top shoulder trigger. The right-hand element has a second analogue stick, the X, Y, A and B input buttons, another shoulder button, a 'Plus' start button and a Home button for jumping to the main interface.

These components can be used together, separately or combined with a central Joy-Con grip unit for a more traditional play experience. The ability to use each part as a solo pad also goes some way to explaining the removal of the old-school Cross pad – with the analogue stick used as a movement input, the other buttons then potentially can be used for action commands, with the pad turned on its side like a spruced-up NES pad.

One criticism so far, based on early play, relates to the right-hand side of the Joy-Con, when it's being used in a single-controller scenario. As it's asymmetrically placed when in the Joy-Con grip, this means that all its buttons and its control stick can feel very cramped together when it's used in a solo configuration.

Another problem that's emerging relates to the syncing of the left controller. There have been widespread reports that the controller has trouble maintaining a strong connection and sometimes drops out during play. This is something we've experienced ourselves.

We've found that the signal between the left controller and the docked console isn't particularly strong and when blocked by something as simple as a body part it can disconnect. This is frustrating and we hope it's a software issue rather than anything to do with the hardware of the Joy-Con controllers themselves. 

Each Joy-Con offers an accelerometer and gyroscope for motion controls, while the right Joy-Con also features NFC for hooking up Nintendo's amiibo figurines. Nintendo is coining what it calls 'HD Rumble' for the controllers, which it claims lets you feel vibrations as subtle as a few ice cubes shaking around in a glass.

The right controller element also features an IR Motion Camera that can detect the distance and shape of objects in particular games – Nintendo offers the example of being able to play rock/paper/scissors with the console, though it does hint at further AR or VR ambitions down the line.


When removed from the tablet, the controllers feel quite unlike any others we've played with before. They're incredibly light and very small too, which may prove fiddly for big-handed gamers. But they also prove responsive – playing the motion-based mini-games of launch title 1-2-Switch worked a treat, while the split D-Pad's buttons are low-profile enough to allow for lightning-fast Street Fighter special moves. When removed from the tablet, each Joy-Con part can have a clip-on set of shoulder buttons slid onto their sides, too.

Again, the flexibility of the controller options makes for a very dynamic system. In theory, for example, you can get four players around one Switch console with two complete Joy-Con controllers, if each player uses an individual left or right side pad. The combinations seem confusing on paper, but in practice should be quite intuitive. Less clear at this point is how many controller in total the Switch supports, once you start including the more traditional Nintendo Switch Pro pads into the mix.

When combined, the Joy-Con controllers felt very light, and certainly portable-friendly. Yes, the right analogue stick is oddly placed but the controller was comfortable to use for a lengthy Zelda playthrough, although we'd probably opt for the Classic Controller Pro if money were no object. 

Games: the launch lineup and beyond

But what’s a games console without the games? The Nintendo Switch has a number of both first- and third-party titles ready to go in the console's first year, including big franchise hitters like Mario and Zelda, although the day one launch lineup is looking a little spartan.

The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild appears the most compelling so far, set for release on March 3 alongside the Switch itself. It'll be joined by 1-2-Switch, a title that makes full use of the controllers and little screen interaction to ensure players are looking into each other's eyes, with mini-games including wildwest gunslinging.

ARMS, a multiplayer futuristic boxing game, uses the Joy-Con pads to throw punches, and will be ready "this spring".

This is essentially Wii Sports boxing mode, spun out into an entire game, with rock-em-sock-em robot visuals. You'll be able to pick different power-ups for each arm (controlled by a Joy-Con component in each hand), jumping and throwing flurries of punches at a split-screen opponent. At present, it's hard to get a grip on just how much skill is involved, as opposed to the flailing limb equivalent of button-mashing – trying to tactically dodge a press event opponent who was windmilling, we didn't stand a chance.

Mario Kart 8 Deluxe makes the superb racer portable, and introduces new courses, items and racers – it'll be ready on April 28.

If you've played Mario Kart 8 on the Wii U, you'll know what to expect here – the game is all but identical, except for the addition of some new items and racers. What you gain, however, is the flexibility of the Switch – this is Mario Kart, in all its HD glory, on the go. Being able to sit around a table with eight other players, each potentially with their own Switch tablet screen, connected over local Wi-Fi, could bring that Blue Shell hyper-competitive play to a whole new level.

Paintball multiplayer shooter Splatoon 2 will be ready for the summer, while the surprisingly engrossing Snipperclips – Cut It Out Together! will launch in March; it's puzzle game that enables you to cut shapes out and bring them into the game to help solve challenges.

So far, it's our dark horse favorite from the whole event. Looking a little like Scribblenauts, players can take one Joy-Con component each, and use it to cut chunks out of each other's paper player. This can then be used to line up with puzzle-solving shapes, or formed into tools to move items around the screen.

In one example, we cut our fellow player's character into a shovel shape, so that she could scoop a basketball into a net. It's very charming, and seemed perfect for playing sat next to another gamer in tablet mode, away from the big screen.

Xenoblade Chronicles 2, meanwhile, with its space-faring mechs, will keep RPG fans happy.

So where's Mario? He'll miss the launch, with Super Mario Odyssey arriving in time for Christmas. It sounds like it'll be worth the wait, though, with Odyssey being the first 'sandbox' Mario game since Super Mario Sunshine on the GameCube, letting you explore wide-open worlds.

A number of third-party titles have also been teased, including EA's FIFA, The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim, NBA 2K, Project Octopath Traveler, Street Fighter II Ultra, Sonic Mania, Super Bomberman, Just Dance, Disegea 5, Dragon Quest's X and XI, Fire Emblem Warriors, and Minecraft.

The issue, as was the case with the N64 and Wii U, will be retaining third-party support. The Switch’s unique hardware, like that of the Wii U, forces additional design considerations upon developers, which can become costly in gruelling development cycles. The Switch seems far more accommodating in this respect than the Wii U ever was, but it’ll be interesting to see if the chicken-and-egg scenario between playerbase and game catalogue can find a happy balance this time around.

The situation should be helped this time around by the fact that the Unreal Engine now fully supports the hardware, which should reduce the complexity of developing for the console, but we'd still consider third-party support for the console to be unproven for now. 

Early verdict

The Switch is a confident showing from Nintendo at this early hands-on stage. Rather than falling on its sword and following the straightforward 'box-under-your-telly' design ethos, Nintendo has taken bold strides to once again mix up the gaming experience. Hopefully, third-party developers will make the jump into the unknown with it.

Flexible and fun, without feeling like a toy, the Switch is proving that Nintendo’s ideas can remain joyously novel without alienating the more po-faced of gamers. While on-the-go battery life and performance remain a concern until we can try out extensive real-world play on the Switch, Nintendo’s new machine is looking very promising; it just needs the games to make use of this innovative hardware.

With a price point set at £279.99 / $299.99 / AU$469.95, the Switch is going to have a mighty fight ahead of it against the relatively affordable PS4 and Xbox One bundles – and that's before we learn more about the Xbox Scorpio, which we'd expect to be far more powerful, but far pricier.

Still, there's nothing like pulling off a Super Mario triple jump, eh?

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Gerald is Associate Editor of TechRadar, taking care of the site's news and features output. He loves his gaming, but don't expect him to play with you unless your console is hooked up to a 4K HDR screen and a 7.1 surround system. Based out of TechRadar Towers, London, Gerald was previously Editor of Gizmodo UK. He dreams of the day when he can pop on a VR headset and meet Lawnmower Man-era Pierce Brosnan. Sadly, Pierce doesn't share the dream.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Jon Porter is Techradar's UK Home Technology Writer covering everything from TVs to Hi-Fi, gaming and home automation. He's also super into keyboards, and I think we can all agree that the obsession has gone a little too far at this point.

What is a hands on review?

'Hands on reviews' are a journalist's first impressions of a piece of kit based on spending some time with it. It may be just a few moments, or a few hours. The important thing is we have been able to play with it ourselves and can give you some sense of what it's like to use, even if it's only an embryonic view. For more information, see TechRadar's Reviews Guarantee.