Updated 43 minutes ago

Microsoft Windows Live Photo Gallery review

Could Windows Live Photo Gallery be the world's free Photoshop?

Our Score 4

Last reviewed: 2010-07-23July 23rd 2010

microsoft-windows-live-photo-gallery

One nifty new feature lets you combine several versions of an image

Everyone carries digital cameras, but not everyone's discovered the importance of editing and managing the hundreds of pictures they can hold. That's where Live Photo Gallery comes in, giving you a one-stop shop for managing, editing and uploading.

It lets you do some very impressive tricks indeed, especially for a free download. Many of the Wave 4 features are familiar from the earlier Essentials releases (and from the original Vista Windows Gallery), with the new version gaining a new look and feel thanks to the Windows 7 iteration of Microsoft's ribbon user interface.

Every section has seen a massive improvement, however, starting with management. Managing images is all about search, and while images aren't the easiest of things to index, Microsoft has made it a lot easier to add captions and tags to them.

One option lets you quickly geo-tag pictures, typing the place name to add where you took the picture to the image metadata (although sadly not in a way that's supported by popular photo-sharing site Flickr).

There's a big improvement to the way Live Photo Gallery tags people too, with a new face-detection tool.

Ready and correct

The image-editing features are the most exciting part of the app. To start with, most of the basic editing features are available in the gallery itself. You can auto-correct, tweak colours and exposure and apply basic image effects without opening images, something that speeds up basic image processing workflow.

Once you open an image and move to the Edit tab, you'll find more image-processing tools, including red eye removal and a Retouch tool that helps to remove blemishes. Unlike other retouch tools, this isn't a healing brush and so it doesn't need you to create an accurate outline around what you want to remove. All you need to do is drag a rectangle around the area you want to change, and let Live Photo Gallery do the rest.

Photo Fuse is another of the brand-new features in this version. If you've taken several photos of a group of people only to find that someone's blinking in each one, you can use this to collect all the open eyes and bring them into one final version.

Select the images and Live Photo Gallery will align them, giving you one base image to work with. Once you've selected the area to edit (typically a head) you'll be shown the alternative content from the other images. You can then drop the section of image you want into place.

Photo Fuse capably blends the images, leaving you with the photo you wanted to take in the first place. It's a surprisingly useful tool and one that gives you effective results for very little effort.

Windows live photo gallery 2

One feature of Live Photo Gallery that often gets overlooked is its ability to launch other image editing tools, like Photosynth and Microsoft Research's advanced image stitching and collage tools. Use the 'More Tools' option in the Create tab to download plug-ins, launch installed applications and open the currently selected images in any other image-editing tools you might have installed on your PC.

Microsoft has also added new upload plug-ins, with support for sharing images on Facebook and videos on YouTube, as well as storing files on its own Windows Live SkyDrive service. The upload tools have had a makeover, so it's now easier to add tags and deliver images to the right online groups and galleries.

Despite its powerful new image editing tools, Live Photo Gallery isn't a replacement for high-end software like Adobe's Lightroom and Photoshop. What it is, however, is a replacement for budget image cataloguing and-editing tools like Photoshop Elements and Corel's Paint Shop Photo Express.

It does the basics well, and at that most compelling of price points: free.

Follow TechRadar Reviews on Twitter: http://twitter.com/techradarreview

Your comments (1) Click to add a new comment

bradavon


July 25th 2010

1. Comparing Windows Live Photo Gallery with Adobe's professional software is a rather pointless one. It's clear Microsoft isn't comparing them. They once sold Microsoft Digital Image Suite (used to be called Picture-IT!) to compete but rightly decided to scrap it (it wasn't a patch on Photoshop). Much of Digital Image Suite was re-used in Vista' Windows Photo Gallery.

It's also no competitor to Photoshop Elements. Elements isn't free and has significantly more features. I'm unsure if the reviewer has used Elements.

Windows Live Photo Gallery is clearly designed for those users who routinely do no editing (not even rotating photos, which is really annoying) and certainly wouldn't consider paying for such software.

Obviously the real reason why most of Windows Live Essentials exists is to compete with Apple's iLife. Which comes pre-installed (I think) on MACs but thankfully Microsoft don't pre-install it on Windows 7.

Windows Live Photo Gallery is very good though and now looks to be even better. Photo Fuse and Face Auto-tagging especially.

Windows Live Photo Gallery 2009 has a plugin for Facebook/YouTube/Picasa, it's good to see Facebook/YouTube is now built in.

It's odd that some of the Microsoft Research tools aren't integrated. Such as PhotoSynth (Free), Image Composite Editor (Free) and the excellent AutoCollage (only £18 anyway). The latter two would especially integrate well.

Alert a moderator

Tell us what you think

You need to Log in or register to post comments

By submitting this form you agree to our Terms of Use and so are legally responsible for anything you submit. DO NOT submit anything which may violate the Terms of Use or another person's rights including copyrighted or offensive materials.

Shopping results for

Windows Live Photo Gallery

Microsoft Windows Live Photo Gallery

On sale for

£52.21

from Dixons

Product Summary

For

>

Photo Fuse

>

Good image editing tools

>

Face detection

>

Management options

Against

>

Not a free photoshop

Recommended for you