How to choose a project management tool

Man holding a pen to paper
(Image credit: Image Credit: StartupStockPhotos / Pixabay)

The process of selecting appropriate project management tools is complicated because it requires organizations to handle multiple technical, organizational, and human factors that determine both system adoption rates and operational success.

The main obstacles that occur during tool selection include undefined project needs, insufficient stakeholder backing, complex system learning requirements and integration problems, restricted customization options, scalability issues, security concerns, compliance issues, and noncompliance.

Try Jira for free

Try Jira for free

Jira Service Management is an IT service and workflow management tool designed for teams that need structure, speed, and clear communication. It helps businesses manage requests, incidents, approvals, and changes in one organised platform. With automation, dashboards, and collaboration tools, it's ideal for teams, operations, and any company looking to streamline service delivery.

Unclear requirements

Project management tool evaluations begin without a clear definition of project objectives, workflow patterns, and essential requirements.

The organization fails to achieve full stakeholder participation because departments do not share information effectively, and stakeholders do not participate in the requirements-gathering process.

The selection of a tool becomes ineffective when requirements remain undefined or when different stakeholders disagree on essential business needs and operational requirements.

Organizations need to conduct comprehensive needs assessments across all departments to select software that meets organizational targets and team-specific requirements.

Lack of stakeholder buy-in

(Image credit: Image Credit: Pixabay / Pexels)

The selection process for project management tools becomes less successful when decision-makers fail to involve project managers and team leads, and end users provide their input.

Selecting a preferred tool without team feedback results in a solution that does not match actual workflows, which causes users to resist the new system and disconnect from it.

The selection process requires a diverse team that represents all organizational levels to achieve successful tool adoption. The selected tool will better serve user needs when it aligns with their actual requirements, leading to higher adoption rates.

Steep learning curve and poor usability

Project management platforms pose complex onboarding challenges because their user interfaces lack intuitive navigation. Users experience confusion from tools that include too many features, while basic tools lack essential capabilities for resource management and progress tracking.

Selecting a tool with an easy-to-use interface and extensive training resources is vital in achieving successful user adoption and minimizing system-related user dissatisfaction.

The transition becomes smoother when organizations provide continuous support through tutorials and dedicated help desks, resulting in higher user satisfaction.

Integration difficulties

Organizations operate multiple systems that handle communication, documentation, and project tracking.

Selecting a tool that fails to integrate correctly with current applications, including Slack for communication and Google Workspace for document management, will create separate workflows and force users to perform duplicate work.

The evaluation process for potential tools should focus on their ability to connect with current software systems. The integration of tools enables process optimization, leading to better teamwork among team members.

Limited customization and scalability

Project management tools often lack flexibility, making it difficult for users to implement their specific project workflows and support organizational growth.

Selecting software that fails to scale with team growth or changes in project methodology will force organizations to perform expensive platform migrations.

Organizations should select software tools that offer adjustable features that expand as the business grows, enabling teams to modify their workflows and operational processes.

Overemphasis on cost

Selecting a tool solely for its affordable price leads organizations to miss out on vital features, including resource planning, mobile access, and advanced technical assistance.

The long-term focus on cost savings through tool selection will create inefficiencies that force organizations to spend money on platform upgrades and additional software acquisitions.

The selection of project management tools should focus on their overall value delivery, as organizations need solutions that meet operational requirements while balancing budget constraints.

Security and compliance risks

Dashlane Business plan review

(Image credit: Dashlane)

Consolidating project data into a single tool creates new security challenges for organizations. Sensitive information can be exposed to unauthorized users when tools lack proper access controls and compliance features, resulting in legal and operational risks for organizations.

Organizations need to select tools that implement advanced security features, including data encryption and user authorization systems, as well as regulatory compliance standards (GDPR and HIPAA), to defend their data and maintain regulatory compliance.

The evaluation process should follow a structured format that includes usability assessment, integration testing, security evaluation, scalability assessment, and team workflow compatibility assessment before selecting the final tool.

The evaluation process leads to better tool selection, which results in improved team member satisfaction and easier system adoption.

Ignoring mobile and remote access

The absence of mobile functionality in hybrid or remote work settings creates barriers to team members communicating and working together effectively.

The ability to access software through mobile devices enables teams to maintain continuous communication and immediate responses regardless of their physical location.

How AI is changing project management tools

The project management tool landscape underwent a complete transformation in 2025, as artificial intelligence enabled intelligent systems to execute tasks with minimal human assistance while anticipating and strategizing.

Organizations use artificial intelligence to boost operational performance, minimize project risks, and make better decisions from start to finish.

Predictive planning and risk assessment

Machine learning

(Image credit: Shahadat Rahman on Unsplash)

The implementation of predictive analytics technology enables teams to detect potential project obstacles such as delays, budget issues, and resource constraints before they become actual issues.

The AI-powered tools Epicflow and Asana use advanced machine learning algorithms to analyze historical data to detect risks and provide immediate recommendations for preventive actions.

The new approach enables teams to stay ahead of schedule by developing predictive capabilities instead of relying on reactive approaches.

Smarter scheduling and resource allocation

The process of scheduling and resource management has been automated through AI systems that create dynamic timelines based on real-time factors, including workforce availability, task dependencies, and workload distribution.

The flexible scheduling system enables businesses to maximize their workforce potential while maintaining exact deadline compliance.

Workflow automation and decision support

The combination of natural language processing and machine learning technology enables organizations to automate administrative work, including project status reporting, work distribution, and report production.

The AI-powered assistants on the Teamwork.com and ClickUp platforms would allow users to ask questions about project performance and receive instant, data-driven answers, reducing reporting time and enabling teams to focus on essential tasks.

AI-enhanced collaboration and communication

AI technology enables teams to work more efficiently by automating meeting summary generation, discussion transcription, and action item list creation.

The AI-powered chatbots on the Wrike and Microsoft Teams platforms enable fast query responses, project metric retrieval, and asynchronous communication, reducing the need for regular meetings.

Human role and strategic focus

Project managers now focus on strategic planning because AI performs most project execution responsibilities. Project managers now serve as strategic leaders who use AI-generated data to direct projects toward business goals.

Key business impact

The combination of predictive analytics with risk management leads to better project success rates and shorter project cycles, as automated scheduling and administrative work become more efficient for all stakeholders.

The implementation of these advanced systems in 2025 enables businesses to achieve higher productivity while reducing expenses and gaining data-driven agility across their projects.

Bryan M Wolfe

Bryan M. Wolfe is a staff writer at TechRadar, iMore, and wherever Future can use him. Though his passion is Apple-based products, he doesn't have a problem using Windows and Android. Bryan's a single father of a 15-year-old daughter and a puppy, Isabelle. Thanks for reading!