Hot on the heels of last year's Britannica 2009 Ultimate Edition, comes – yes, you've guessed it – the 2010 edition.
It's a multimedia version of the famous encyclopaedia that bills itself as 'three encyclopaedias in one' because it comes with a Child's Library, for ages 6-10, a Student Library aimed at students aged 10-14 and the full Encyclopaedia Britannica Library.
Each of these has an age-appropriate interface. Once you've registered there's also a year's worth of free online updates to the encyclopaedia; you also get six months' free membership to the online version of Encyclopaedia Britannica, worth £25.
The online version is very good, and many might find it more useful than this DVD based version, since you can use it anywhere you can get an internet connection. However, the 2009 edition gave us a full year's membership, rather than just six months, so we have to call foul here.
Up to date?
How you rate an encyclopaedia depends on what you'll use it for. For historical topics such as the English Civil Wars and Henry VIII, it proved to be comprehensive, offering pictures, dates, links to extra info and more.
But for the sort of things a technology journalist would be interested in, such as SSD or RAID, there was nothing. Its entry on Apple, Inc was well written, but felt old. It seemed to trail off after the iPhone 3G was released, with no mention of the iPhone 3GS, App Store or iPod touch.
Its entry for Steve Jobs was even more out of date, with no mention of anything that has happened to him post 1998. In comparison, the free online encyclopaedia, www.wikipedia.com has much more current information.
The books it recommends as additional reading don't link to Amazon and there are no links to websites outside of Britannica.
Another year on and Britannica seems even more old-fashioned. It's like a relic from the bygone era of multimedia CD-ROMs.
Take its atlas, for example. In these days of Google Earth and Google Maps, we expect to click on a country and watch the screen zoom in, then we should be able to pan around a scaleable map until we have found what we're looking for.
Instead you get a 2D flattened globe, and clicking on a country takes you to a single, low-res, tiny map that shows you little more than the outline of the country.
On the positive side, when it comes to accuracy of information, Britannica delivers. Everything it contains is well written and accurate. We also really liked the BrainStormer feature that enables you to search for related content in a visual way. It's also safer than letting the kids play around on the internet to research their homework.
The big problem remains, however, that while free resources like Wikipedia can never claim the same level of accuracy as Britannica, they are, in comparison, free, provided you have internet access.
Follow TechRadar Reviews on Twitter: http://twitter.com/techradarreview
Your comments (1) Click to add a new comment
methodman
June 25th 2010
1. I think if you want what you want (and I strongly dislike your Mac fanboy review. You should review Encarta. Their history of computers omits the Amiga, the C64 worlds best selling computer. The Atari ST the X68000 and pretends that the only computer manufactures are pc and Mac what a boatload of lies.
Having said that Encyclopedia Britannica should partner with Wolfram and Maple and the three of them ought to kick out an interactive science encyclopedia. The materials are made; problem is no one knows how to teach math. Macintosh is entirely about software applications. PC has many sdk available for it but there are more magazines that are available for the C64 and Amiga then there are for Mac and PC to explain programming. Linux has many examples but not very many magazines are produced for it.
Programming is not easy and to pretend it is is to continue the over-simplication mentality. Britannica is fabulous but the tech history is so out in the open that it is unecessary for it to deal with it. bombjack.org/commodore magazines try info magazine.
Alert a moderator
Tell us what you think
You need to Log in or register to post comments