Hollywood studios left red-faced after losing ISP download case

Judge rules in favour of the ISP

Hollywood's battle with web pirates hit a significant road bump this week, when it lost a copyright case in Australia.

A number of Hollywood studios – including Warner Bros, Disney and 20th Century Fox – were behind the action against Australian ISP iiNet, which accused the service provider of allowing its users to download copyrighted content and blamed the company for not putting anti-piracy measures in place.

This was in 2010 and the lawsuit was eventually quashed when the court ruled in favour of iiNet, but the 35 movie and TV companies involved in the case decided to push ahead with an appeal.

Skip to 2012 and that appeal has been lost, with the court backing its original ruling that iiNet did not authorise the apparently illegal downloads or have the power to stop them.

No authorisation

"The High Court held that the respondent, an Internet service provider (ISP), had not authorised the infringement by its customers of the appellants' copyright in commercially released films and television programmes," said the court's statement.

Warner Bros and co aren't exactly happy with this ruling, with a spokesman for the Australian Federation Against Copyright Theft (AFACT) saying about the judgement: "Both judgements in this case recognise that copyright law is no longer equipped to deal with the rate of technological change we have seen since the law of authorisation was last tested."

The ruling does have massive implications for the rest of the world. If courts aren't going to fine or punish ISPs for copyright infringement, then a lot of them might be thinking that going down the 'three strikes and you are out' road for repeat infringers might not be the right thing to do.

Via Phys.org

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Content Team Lead

Marc (Twitter, Google+) is the content team lead for Future Technology, where he is in charge of a 14-strong team of journalists who write many of the wonderful stories that end up on TechRadar, T3.com and T3 magazine. Prior to this he was deputy editor of TechRadar, had a 10-month stint editing a weekly iPad magazine, written film reviews for a whole host of publications and has been an integral part of many magazines that are no longer with us.