Updated 1 hour ago

11300 products + 4866 members

Home cinema News

Never mind the hype, is Digital IMAX any good?

TechRadar watches the Watchmen (trailer) in Greenwich

December 4th 2008 | Tell us what you think [ 4 comments ]

we-re-hoping-the-real-tickets-will-be-a-little-less-ostentatious

We're hoping the real tickets will be a little less ostentatious

ZoomZoom

<>

TechRadar was present at the launch of Digital IMAX in Europe, as Greenwich's Odeon cinema showed off the technology that is sweeping across the world's picture houses.

Digital IMAX is, as you may have gathered, a digital version of the already established IMAX technology, which is easier to implement and can be built in many existing cinemas.

Obviously, the hope is that the enhanced experience will bring a resurgence for cinemas as they battle against big screen televisions and high definition media like Blu-ray.

But is it any good?

IMAX Executive Vice President Larry O'Reilly introduced a show reel of some of the best IMAX material including trailers from past and present films, an animated 3D short and a few clips.

The digital films in the selection really shone – with the highlight being the widely circulated trailer for Watchmen – one of next year's most eagerly awaited movies.

The visuals are simply stunning – the big screen and the ratio draw you into the action, and although you could perhaps suggest that some of the detail around the outside is lost because you are forced to focus your attention on one part of the screen it works to draw you in.

Sounds like...

But it is the sound as much as anything that impresses. The IMAX sound system is hand assembled for each cinema with the speakers 'laser-positioned' in the hope that the sweet spot for the sound can be extended beyond the range of rival systems.

There was much talk about subtle sounds being accurately represented, but as you can imagine it was the big booming noises that really shook things up – quite literally in fact as the bass vibrated through the chairs.

Lest you imagine that it is only digital films that are going to shine on the Digital IMAX, a song from the Rolling Stones concert was boomed out as well. And, if you'll excuse the cheese, even though Mick Jagger didn't get any satisfaction, those in the audience certainly did.

The third dimension

The 3D promotion was everything you would expect, the cheaper 3D glasses are okay and the picture sharp, although Dolby's rival 3D technology certainly gives it a run for its money.

As with most things 3D, there is that horrible tendency to try to focus on the wrong bit to force it flat which can be headache inducing, as can Madagascar 2's colours, but as your mind lets it go and it washes over you things improve.

There's a lot to be said for the implementation of next generation viewing in cinemas. It's not gone unnoticed that people are choosing to curl up in front of their plasma screens with the DVD rather than forking out on expensive cinema tickets.

Value added

But if the viewing experience is something that you cannot replicate at home then the few extra quid you will fork out on Digital IMAX films (and the adult weekend tickets will be priced at a not inconsiderable £11.50) begins to look a little more justifiable.

In truth it will be the likes of Watchmen, and of course James Cameron's long-awaited Avatar, that truly test if IMAX is the jolt that modern cinemas need.

As experiences go, however, it would take a pretty special bit of home cinema kit to even begin to approach the visceral viewing experience of the Digital IMAX.

Comment on this article
 

Your comments (4) Click to add a new comment

tech89

December 5th 2008

4. I would love to go and see watchman in an IMAX cinema, especially if it only costs £11-15 for the amazing quality. However theres only one in London, what good is that to me in the west midlands nera Birmingham? Trey rolling out some IMAX cinemas in the rest of the country. The whole population doesn't live in london. Hurry up IMAX and fit an IMAX screen in the wext midlands. I' waiting...

Alert a moderator

blueskythinker

December 4th 2008

3. @Nitrofan - Lazy commenting more like. The hype in the title is in reference to IMAX Digital, not The Watchmen (which I think deserves all the hype it is getting).

And yes Digital Cinemas have been hyped as the future of cinema, but us in the UK haven't seen much progress in this area.

I for one think that Digital IMAX's are a good thing. People need a reason to go to the cinema now and not sit at home. If the price of watching reflected the experience then more people would pay.

You pay £15 to get in your average nightclub, so spending that for a few hours in the cinema isn't that bad - especially if what you are watching is 3D, or in crystal clear quality.

Alert a moderator

nicolasmerritt

December 4th 2008

2. @nitrofan:

The author did not say, 'sweeping London', he said "sweeping the world's picture houses". IMAX should have around 50 of its 290 odd global sites converted to digital by the end of this year.

Watchmen is certainly eagerly awaited - it's one of the most famous and critically acclaimed comic book series of recent times. Look it up.

Alert a moderator

nitrofan

December 4th 2008

1. "The digital films in the selection really shone – with the highlight being the widely circulated trailer for Watchmen – one of next year's most eagerly awaited movies."

A few observations on your piece,

1. "the technology that is sweeping across the world's picture houses." Get real we have ONE Digital IMAX in London!

2. Cinema is under threat from inflated charges, over priced refreshments and the fact you have no control over a tall person sitting in front of you negates ANY high quality presentation instantly, as does people talking etc etc. NOT from big TV's!

3. Given how much IMAX is supposed to cost it should be able to reproduce digital films well!

3. Your strapline says and I quote "never mind the hype" - so why start hyping a film? Who on earth is "eagerly awaiting" this film? apart from the marketing departments of its producer! your comments are nonsense.

Yet more lazy journalism not good enough TechRadar!

Alert a moderator

Tell us what you think

You need to Log in or register to post comments

By submitting this form you agree to our Terms of Use and so are legally responsible for anything you submit. DO NOT submit anything which may violate the Terms of Use or another person's rights including copyrighted or offensive materials.

Download the Flash plugin